Detox Guide · Grilling and Frying

Acrylamide and Grilling: Which Substances Form During High-Heat Cooking and How You Can Reduce Them

Acrylamide, HCAs and PAHs form when food is cooked at high heat. Here you will find out what studies show and which simple steps can reduce their formation.

Acrylamide from about 120 °C (BfR) 53% fewer PAHs with a black beer marinade (lab) 48 to 89% fewer PAHs without fat in the embers (lab) Don't store potatoes below 8 °C (EFSA)
SJShukri Jarmoukli · Physician, Integrative Medicine · ViveCura Berlin
Why I'm writing this

I don't want to take grilling away from you. I want to show you where small steps can make a big difference. Golden, not charred, is not about going without. It's about craft.

An everyday scene

Imagine it's Saturday evening. The grill is smoking, everyone is hungry, and you turn the sausages a moment too late.

One side is black. Someone calls out: “Just cut the black bit off, it'll be fine.”

You nod. And yet a quiet question lingers: is that actually true?

This scene is an everyday example, not a patient story. It raises a question and does not claim any causal link between a barbecue evening and an illness.

The short answer: cutting it off is better than nothing. But it is only the last step. Here you will find out which three groups of substances form during high-heat cooking, what studies show and which levers can make the biggest difference.

How to read the study boxes

  • Meta-analysis An evaluation of many observational studies in humans.
  • Human Measurements in humans, here with very few participants.
  • Animal study Experiments in mice. Whether the results apply to humans is open.
  • Lab Grilling, frying and storage experiments with food, measured in the lab.

Assessments by authorities such as the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) appear in separate boxes headed “Assessment” or “Recommendation”.

Is it enough to cut off the black bits?

In short: High-heat cooking produces three groups of substances, and the knife only catches some of them. In a lab experiment, PAHs fell by 48 to 89 percent when no more fat dripped into the embers.

Your gut says: the black part is the problem, so get rid of it. Your head suspects it can't be that simple. Both are a little bit right.

Grilling, frying and baking mainly produce three groups of substances. They come from different sources and sit in different places. That is exactly why the knife doesn't catch everything.

Acrylamide

The starch substance

WhereIn starchy foods such as potatoes, bread and baked goods, and also in coffee.

HowFrom the amino acid asparagine and sugars, according to the BfR from about 120 °C, particularly strongly from 170 to 180 °C.

PictureLike caramel: the darker the crust, the more acrylamide it can contain.

HCAs

Heterocyclic amines

WhereMainly in meat that is seared or grilled at high heat.

HowFrom creatine, amino acids and sugars in muscle meat, according to the NCI mainly above about 150 °C.

PictureThey form in the meat itself, especially where it gets hottest.

PAHs

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

WhereOn the surface of grilled food, especially over open embers.

HowFat and meat juices drip into the embers and burn, and the smoke carries the substances back onto the food.

PictureLike the soot a flickering candle paints on the wall.

In common

What all three share

HeatThe hotter and the longer, the more can form.

WaterBoiling and steaming stay at about 100 °C, below these thresholds.

LeverYou can influence how much forms, not just cut away the result.

Now back to the question from Saturday evening. According to the BfR, cutting off charred areas can reduce your intake. The National Cancer Institute in the USA also recommends it. So cutting it off is not a myth, but a sensible step.

But there are two catches. First, PAHs arrive with the smoke. They settle on the entire surface, not just where it is black. Second, according to the BfR, even moderately browned areas can already contain a lot of acrylamide. This mainly concerns potatoes, bread and baked goods that are on the grill as well.

In the sausage itself, acrylamide plays a smaller role, because meat contains hardly any starch. Here it is mainly about HCAs and PAHs.

Assessment by the BfR

The German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment sums up its advice in three words: golden, not charred. Food should not be heated more strongly or for longer than necessary. When baking, frying and deep-frying, you should avoid temperatures above 180 °C where possible.

Does any of this actually reach the body? A small but revealing study looked into exactly this question.

Human, 4 participants

A team led by Rothman had four healthy non-smokers eat about 280 grams of charcoal-grilled beef every day for a week. In two of them, PAH bonds to the DNA of white blood cells rose by a factor of three to six, in the other two they did not. What this means for you: what forms on the grill can reach your body, but people respond to it very differently.

Rothman et al., Carcinogenesis 1990

Four people is a very small number. The study says nothing about cancer risk. But it does show that the question is not just theoretical.

  • Cut off charred bits: This remains sensible, even if it doesn't catch everything.
  • Turn earlier: Better to turn more often than once too late.
  • Keep away from the flames: Don't put food directly into open flames.
Reframe

The question is not whether you cut off the black part. The question is why it turns black in the first place. If you control the heat, you'll have less to cut away later.

And now you know why the knife is only the last step and not the most important one.

Acrylamide: golden, not charred

In short: After heating, carbohydrate-rich foods contained 150 to 4000 micrograms of acrylamide per kilogram. Raw or boiled, they were below 5.

Potato wedges from the grill, crispy on the outside, almost black at the edges. For many people, that is the best part. And that is exactly where a second look is worthwhile.

Acrylamide forms when two building blocks meet: the amino acid asparagine and sugar. Imagine a dance that only begins in great heat. Below about 120 °C, the two dancers mostly stay at the edge of the floor. Above that, they find each other, and the result is browning, aroma and also acrylamide. Experts call this dance the Maillard reaction.

As long as there is plenty of water involved, the temperature stays at about 100 °C. That is why boiling and steaming produce hardly any acrylamide. Only when the surface dries out does the dance floor fill up.

Lab, food analyses

A team from Stockholm University tested heated foods for acrylamide and estimated intake via bonds to haemoglobin. After heating, carbohydrate-rich foods contained 150 to 4000 micrograms per kilogram, while raw or boiled they were below 5. What this means for you: it's not the food alone that matters, but above all how you heat it.

Tareke et al., J Agric Food Chem 2002
Lab, model experiments

In 2002, two teams led by Mottram in Reading and Stadler in Lausanne investigated where acrylamide comes from. Independently of each other, both found that it forms from asparagine and sugar in the Maillard reaction. What this means for you: because we know the ingredients of the dance, there are several points where you can step in.

Mottram et al., Nature 2002 · Stadler et al., Nature 2002
from 120 °Cacrylamide starts to form (BfR)
170 to 180 °Cfrom here it forms particularly strongly (BfR)
64%higher intake possible when fried potatoes are cooked until crispy brown (EFSA)

So how much acrylamide ends up on your plate also depends on the colour. And that is good news, because the colour is in your hands.

Assessment by EFSA

In 2015, the European Food Safety Authority concluded that acrylamide can damage DNA. For this reason, it did not set a tolerable daily intake. An EFSA panel confirmed this assessment in 2022.

According to EFSA, people in Europe take in an average of 0.4 to 1.9 micrograms per kilogram of body weight per day. The BfR compares this amount with a reference dose from animal studies at which tumours occurred more frequently. On average, the reference dose is only 89 to 425 times higher than our intake. For substances that damage DNA, only a margin of 10,000 or more is considered of low concern.

For possible cancer effects, EFSA therefore sees reason for concern. For nerves, reproduction and development, however, it saw none at the usual amounts.

And what do studies in humans show? Here the picture becomes much blurrier.

Meta-analysis, 32 publications

A team led by Pelucchi analysed 32 publications on dietary acrylamide and cancer in humans. For most common cancers they found no association, but among non-smoking women there were slightly increased values for endometrial and ovarian cancer. What this means for you: a moderate association cannot be ruled out, so caution in the kitchen is sensible.

Pelucchi et al., Int J Cancer 2015
Pregnancy, breastfeeding and children

Relative to their body weight, children take in the most acrylamide. According to EFSA, fried and deep-fried potatoes can account for up to half of their intake. According to the BfR, acrylamide can also cross the placenta and pass into breast milk. For pregnant and breastfeeding women and for families, going for golden is therefore especially worthwhile.

  • Golden yellow, not dark brown: Only heat potatoes, French fries and toast until they are golden yellow.
  • Not above 180 °C: Try not to exceed this temperature when baking, frying and deep-frying.
  • Cook with moisture: Boiling and steaming produce hardly any acrylamide and are good alternatives.
  • Mix it up: Not fried, deep-fried or roasted potato and grain products every day.
Reframe

Golden, not charred sounds like going without. Really, it's a question of timing: the pan stays, the crust stays, only the last few minutes are dropped.

And now you know why golden yellow is the smarter colour when it comes to acrylamide.

Marinating, turning, pre-cooking: fewer HCAs in meat

In short: In the lab, marinades with herbs and spices reduced HCAs in grilled steaks by 57 to 88 percent. Frequent turning and brief pre-cooking can also help.

Perhaps you know the grilling rule: only turn meat once, or it won't turn out well. It sounds like experience and is often defended with conviction. But when it comes to HCAs, it's worth looking at the studies.

Imagine the crust as a small workshop. In great heat, it assembles new substances from creatine, amino acids and sugar. Some of them are HCAs. According to the NCI, they can cause cancer in animal studies.

How much forms depends on temperature, cooking time and the surface. You can intervene at all three points.

Lab, grilling experiment with beef steaks

A team at Kansas State University marinated beef steaks for one hour and grilled them at 204 °C. Depending on the herb and spice marinade, the steaks contained 57 to 88 percent fewer HCAs than without a marinade. What this means for you: besides flavour, a herb marinade can also mean considerably fewer HCAs.

Smith et al., J Food Sci 2008

The researchers suspect that antioxidant plant compounds in the spices are the reason. They could slow down the workshop in the crust to some extent.

Lab, grilling experiment with chicken

A team led by Salmon grilled chicken marinated in brown sugar, olive oil, cider vinegar, garlic, mustard, lemon and salt. This reduced the content of the HCA called PhIP by 92 to 99 percent. What this means for you: a marinade can make a big difference, but the ingredients matter.

Salmon et al., Food Chem Toxicol 1997
Be careful with sugar in the marinade

In the same study, another HCA called MeIQx rose more than tenfold after 30 to 40 minutes of grilling. The mutagenic activity was also higher after 40 minutes. Sugar is a mechanistically plausible reason, because it is one of the building blocks of HCAs. Sweet marinades are therefore better suited to short grilling times.

The next lever comes in even earlier, before the meat even goes on the grill.

Lab, frying experiment with beef

A team led by Felton pre-cooked beef patties in the microwave for up to three minutes before frying. The HCA precursors fell by up to 30 percent and the mutagenic activity by up to 95 percent. What this means for you: briefly pre-cooking and pouring away the juice can make a big difference when frying and grilling.

Felton et al., Food Chem Toxicol 1994

The four HCAs measured were also three to nine times lower afterwards. What matters is really pouring away the juice that has come out. It contains the building blocks that could otherwise turn into HCAs in the crust.

Lab, frying experiment with minced beef

A team led by Salmon fried minced beef patties at different temperatures and turned some of them every minute. Frequently turned patties contained considerably fewer HCAs and even reached the germ-killing core temperature of 70 °C sooner. What this means for you: turning more often takes hardly any extra time and can lower HCAs without leaving the meat raw.

Salmon et al., J Natl Cancer Inst 2000
  • Marinate for about an hour: Let herb and spice marinades soak in before grilling.
  • Go easy on sugar: Only apply sweet glazes in the last few minutes.
  • Turn more often: Better to turn every minute than once too late.
  • Pre-cook briefly: Pre-cook meat briefly in the microwave, pour away the juice, then put it on the grill.
  • Cook through without charring: Cook minced meat thoroughly. In the experiment, the target was 70 °C in the core. The crust doesn't have to turn black for that.
Reframe

Turning only once is considered a pro rule. For HCAs, frequent turning is the smarter choice: the surface keeps getting a break from the heat.

And now you know why marinating and frequent turning are more than a matter of taste.

PAHs: embers, fat and smoke

In short: In the lab, PAHs fell by 48 to 89 percent without dripping fat. A black beer marinade reduced eight PAHs by 53 percent.

You know the sound. Fat drips into the embers, there's a hiss, a flame shoots up. For many people, it's as much a part of grilling as the smell.

That is exactly the moment PAHs form. The fat burns incompletely, and the rising smoke carries the substances upwards. Imagine a chimney with a backdraught: the smoke doesn't end up outside, but directly on your food.

Lab, grilling experiment with pork and beef

A team from South Korea grilled pork and beef over charcoal and measured four PAHs. Without dripping fat, PAHs fell by 48 to 89 percent, and without smoke by 41 to 74 percent. What this means for you: with PAHs, it's mainly the fat dripping into the embers that counts.

Lee et al., Food Chem 2016

In this experiment, evenly glowing charcoal also reduced PAHs. So only put the food on once the flames have died down and the embers are glowing steadily.

A grill tray catches fat and juices before they drip into the embers. Stainless steel trays are a good choice for this. Aluminium foil and aluminium trays don't go well with acidic marinades, because acid can leach aluminium. You can read about which materials make sense in the kitchen in the article on cookware and harmful substances.

Even simpler: push the charcoal to the sides and put the food in the middle. Then the fat doesn't drip into the embers, and you grill with indirect heat.

And then there is a surprising ingredient that was studied in Portugal.

Lab, grilling experiment with pork

A team from the University of Porto marinated pork in three different beer marinades before grilling it over charcoal. The black beer marinade reduced eight PAHs by 53 percent, non-alcoholic Pilsner by 25 percent and regular Pilsner by 13 percent. What this means for you: the more free radicals a marinade can scavenge, the fewer PAHs might form.

Viegas et al., J Agric Food Chem 2014
53%fewer PAHs with a black beer marinade
25%fewer PAHs with non-alcoholic Pilsner
13%fewer PAHs with regular Pilsner

Why black beer of all things? The researchers measured how well each marinade can scavenge free radicals. In the test, black beer reached 68 percent, regular Pilsner only 29.5 percent. Imagine free radicals as sparks from which new PAHs can form in the heat. A marinade with lots of radical scavengers can catch some of these sparks.

It's about the marinade, not about drinking

Alcohol is a risk factor for cancer in its own right. So the black beer marinade is no reason to drink more beer. Non-alcoholic Pilsner also reduced PAHs by 25 percent. In other studies, herb and spice marinades considerably reduced HCAs, without any alcohol at all.

  • Use a grill tray: It catches fat and juices before they drip into the embers.
  • Charcoal to the sides: Put the food in the middle, with no embers directly underneath.
  • Wait until the flames are gone: Evenly glowing charcoal instead of blazing flames.
  • Marinate: Black beer or herbs and spices, with little sugar.
  • Trim the fat: Lean cuts drip less.
Reframe

Smoke is not just flavour, it's also a means of transport. If no fat drips into the embers, it has less to carry.

And now you know why the hiss in the embers reveals more than just heat.

Potatoes: storage and pre-boiling

In short: In a storage experiment, the acrylamide in deep-fried potatoes was closely linked to the sugar content, which explained about 84 percent of the differences. So how cold you store potatoes also counts.

After shopping, the potatoes go into the fridge. Cool keeps things fresh, that's what we learned. With potatoes, this doesn't quite add up.

Potatoes store their energy as starch. Imagine the starch as a large banknote. If the potato gets too cold, it changes part of it into small change, in other words into sugar. Experts call this cold-induced sweetening.

Remember the dance from the section on acrylamide? Sugar is one of the two dancers. More sugar in the potato means asparagine finds more dance partners during frying.

Lab, storage experiment with potatoes

A team from Ghent University stored several potato varieties at 4 °C and at 8 °C and then deep-fried them. Potatoes stored at 4 °C contained more sugar and formed more acrylamide than those stored at 8 °C. What this means for you: the fridge is the wrong place for potatoes, a cool, dark spot suits them better.

De Wilde et al., J Agric Food Chem 2005

The study also had some good news. When the potatoes were then stored at 15 °C for three weeks, the sugar fell again. A fridge is usually considerably colder than 8 °C.

Recommendation by EFSA

According to the European Food Safety Authority, storing potatoes below about 8 °C can increase their sugar content. When they are fried, more acrylamide can form as a result. EFSA names boiling and steaming as alternatives to frying.

The BfR also has a tip that fits well with grilling. According to the BfR, fried potatoes made from pre-boiled potatoes contain less acrylamide than those made from raw ones. Here, more water means less acrylamide. For the grill, this means: boil potatoes beforehand and only brown them briefly to golden yellow on the grill.

And coffee? It contains acrylamide because the beans are roasted. According to the BfR, it is one of the foods with higher levels. The same idea applies here as with grilling: variety rather than going without. You can read about the role coffee can play for the liver in the article on foods for the detox phases.

  • Cool, but not cold: Store potatoes in a dark, cool place, not in the fridge.
  • Pre-boil: Boil potatoes for fried potatoes or the grill beforehand and then only brown them briefly.
  • Stay golden yellow: Only roast potato wedges on the grill until they are golden yellow, too.
  • Potatoes from the fridge: Better to boil or steam them than to fry or deep-fry them.
Reframe

The fridge is seen as the safest place for fresh food. For potatoes, it's more like a small sugar factory. Cool yes, cold no: that's the better rule here.

And now you know why the fridge is the wrong place for potatoes.

Sausages: processed meat and the grill

In short: According to the IARC, the risk of bowel cancer rises by about 18 percent for every 50 grams of processed meat per day. This refers to daily consumption, not a single barbecue evening.

Back to Saturday evening. The sausage is on your plate, and you've cut off the black side. And yet a quiet doubt may remain: is the sausage itself already the problem?

Sausages are processed meat. This means meat that has been salted, cured, fermented or smoked to make it keep longer or taste better. Examples include sausages, ham and salami.

Evaluation, IARC working group

In 2015, a team led by Bouvard summarised the IARC's evaluation of red and processed meat. The working group classified processed meat as carcinogenic to humans, mainly because of bowel cancer, and red meat as probably carcinogenic. What this means for you: with sausages, it's not just the crust that counts, but also how often they end up on your plate.

Bouvard et al., Lancet Oncol 2015
Assessment by the IARC

The WHO's International Agency for Research on Cancer places processed meat in Group 1, the same group as smoking. But this does not mean that both are equally dangerous. The group describes how strong the evidence is, not how large the risk is.

According to the IARC, the risk of bowel cancer rises by about 18 percent for every 50 grams of processed meat per day. Whether the cooking method changes the risk could not be clarified with the available data.

The 18 percent is a relative figure. It describes how much an already existing risk rises if you eat processed meat every day. A single barbecue party is not what this is about.

On the grill, two things come together: the processed meat itself and the substances from the heat. If the sausage chars, HCAs and PAHs can also form. You can reduce these substances with the levers from the previous sections. With the processed meat itself, what matters most is how often it ends up on your plate.

Variety on the grill makes this easier. Vegetables and mushrooms contain no creatine, which is why, according to the NCI, hardly any HCAs form in them. You still shouldn't char them, though, because other charred foods can also contain PAHs.

  • Medium heat: Grill sausages over medium heat and turn them often until they are golden brown all over.
  • Use a grill tray: That way, the fat from the sausage doesn't drip into the embers.
  • Variety on the grill: Vegetables, mushrooms or grilling cheese alongside or instead of sausages.
  • Sparingly in everyday life: Sausage and ham as the exception rather than a daily routine.
Reframe

The sausage is not the enemy of summer. What matters is whether it stays the exception or becomes a daily habit. The one barbecue evening weighs less than the many days in between.

And now you know why it's not just the black side of the sausage that counts.

What happens in the body and what you can do with it

In short: In mice without the enzyme CYP2E1, there were 52 to 66 times fewer glycidamide bonds to DNA. So part of the risk might only arise when the body converts the substance.

After so many numbers, you may be wondering: and what does my body do with all this? Perhaps the next barbecue evening now feels like a walk through a minefield.

Here's the good news: your body is not defenceless. It has a whole team that converts foreign substances, packages them and takes them out.

With acrylamide, however, this team plays a double role. An enzyme called CYP2E1, found mainly in the liver, converts acrylamide into glycidamide. Unlike acrylamide itself, glycidamide can easily attach to DNA.

Imagine you are taking apart an old appliance for the recycling centre. As you unscrew it, a sharp edge is briefly exposed. Glycidamide is that sharp edge.

Animal study, mice

A team led by Ghanayem gave acrylamide to normal mice and to mice without the enzyme CYP2E1 and then examined their DNA. In the mice without CYP2E1, there were 52 to 66 times fewer glycidamide bonds to DNA. What this means for you: the breakdown product glycidamide in particular could explain why acrylamide is considered to damage DNA.

Ghanayem et al., Toxicol Sci 2005

These are data from mice. They show a pathway in metabolism, not your personal risk.

Fortunately, your body also knows a second route: packaging. Glutathione, an antioxidant your body makes itself, can bind acrylamide and glycidamide. Packaged like this, both substances can leave the body via the urine. You can read more about this in the article on glutathione, the master antioxidant.

What happens in the body: four lenses

Metabolism

According to the NCI, HCAs and PAHs, too, only become substances that can damage DNA through certain enzymes in the body. How active these enzymes are can vary from person to person. This could explain why the four non-smokers in the grilling study responded so differently. You can read how this conversion works in the article on phase 1 and phase 2 liver detoxification.

Immune system

White blood cells are the guardians of your immune defence. It was precisely in their DNA that the grilling study found more PAH bonds in two of four participants. According to the BfR, it is also being discussed whether acrylamide can promote oxidative stress. Whether and how much this affects immune defence in humans is open.

Nervous system

Acrylamide can attach directly to proteins, such as haemoglobin, the red pigment in blood. Researchers use these bonds to measure intake. At high doses, such bonds at nerve endings could disrupt the transmission of signals. For nerve damage in animal studies, EFSA used a reference point of 0.43 milligrams per kilogram of body weight per day. Average intake is more than 200 times lower, so EFSA sees no reason for concern here.

Hormonal system

Animal studies with high doses showed effects on male fertility and on development before and after birth. At usual intake levels, EFSA sees no reason for concern in this. According to the BfR, however, acrylamide can cross the placenta and pass into breast milk. Whether it interferes with hormone balance in humans is open.

What is well established and what remains open

Well established

  • Acrylamide, HCAs and PAHs form during high-heat cooking.
  • According to EFSA, acrylamide can damage DNA, and a safe lower limit cannot be given.
  • PAHs on grilled food come mainly from fat dripping into the embers and from the smoke.
  • Potatoes stored in the cold produce more acrylamide when fried, because they form more sugar.
  • The IARC classifies processed meat as carcinogenic to humans.

Plausible, but not conclusively proven

  • That lab results on marinating, turning and pre-cooking apply to your kitchen.
  • That fewer of these substances in food also means a lower risk.
  • That other marinades with many radical scavengers perform similarly to black beer.

Open

  • How large the cancer risk from dietary acrylamide is in humans.
  • Whether the cooking method changes the cancer risk from meat.
  • How much people differ in how they convert these substances and what this means for their risk.
My position as a physician

In my clinical practice, I observe that people quickly fall into two camps when it comes to harmful substances. Some say: there's always something, so who cares. Others hardly dare go near the grill anymore.

I can understand both reactions well. In between lies a calm path: knowing the big levers and taking the small things in your stride.

I wouldn't want to talk anyone out of a summer barbecue evening. What carries more weight for me is what ends up on the plate every day and how it is prepared.

This is my position from clinical practice, not a study.

Because in the end, this isn't about micrograms and percentages. It's about the summer evening with friends, the smell of the grill and children laughing at the table. When you know your levers, you can enjoy it without grilling a guilty conscience along with it. Health is not going without. Health is the freedom to enjoy with a good feeling.

Mindful grilling doesn't mean going without. It means: golden, not charred.

Three levers for your next barbecue evening

  • Golden, not charred: Grill over medium heat and turn often. Golden brown is the goal, not black.
  • Keep fat away from the embers: Use a grill tray or push the charcoal to the sides. And marinate with herbs, spices or black beer.
  • Prepare potatoes properly: Store them somewhere cool and dark, not in the fridge. Pre-boil them before grilling and brown them only briefly.
Reframe

Detox doesn't only begin in the liver. It begins at the grill, in the kitchen and when you shop. What never forms in the first place is something your body doesn't have to convert later.

How you can ease the load on your body in everyday life in other ways is something you can read about in the article Gentle everyday detox without a cleanse.

And now you know why the best detox is the one you never need in the first place.

Frequently asked questions about acrylamide and grilling

What is acrylamide and where is it found?

Acrylamide forms when starchy foods are baked, fried, deep-fried, roasted or grilled. It is produced from the amino acid asparagine and sugars in what is known as the Maillard reaction. According to the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), higher levels are found in crisps, French fries, potato pancakes, fried potatoes, crispbread, biscuits and coffee, for example.

At what temperature does acrylamide form?

According to the BfR, acrylamide forms from about 120 °C, and particularly strongly from 170 to 180 °C. This requires dry heat with little moisture. Boiling in water and steaming produce hardly any acrylamide.

Is it enough to cut off the charred parts?

Cutting them off can reduce your intake and is therefore sensible. However, the BfR points out that even moderately browned areas can already contain a lot of acrylamide. PAHs also settle on the surface via the smoke, not only on the black areas. It is better to avoid charring in the first place.

Is grilling carcinogenic?

When you grill over open embers, substances such as PAHs and HCAs can form that can cause cancer in animal studies. According to the IARC, the available data could not clarify whether the cooking method changes the cancer risk in humans. A barbecue evening is no reason to panic, but it is worth reducing the formation of these substances.

Which marinade can reduce harmful substances when grilling?

In a lab experiment at the University of Porto, a black beer marinade reduced eight PAHs in grilled pork by 53 percent. At Kansas State University, marinades with herbs and spices reduced HCAs in beef steaks by 57 to 88 percent. Sugary marinades tend to be unfavourable with long grilling times.

What does a grill tray do?

A grill tray catches fat and meat juices before they drip into the embers. In a Korean study, PAHs fell by 48 to 89 percent when no more fat dripped into the embers. Stainless steel trays are a good choice, aluminium foil with acidic marinades less so.

Does pre-cooking in the microwave help?

In a lab experiment, briefly pre-cooking beef patties in the microwave reduced the HCA precursors by up to 30 percent. The mutagenic activity after frying fell by up to 95 percent. It is important to pour away the juice that comes out.

How should I store potatoes?

Cool, dark and dry, but not in the fridge. Below about 8 °C, potatoes form more sugar, from which more acrylamide can form during frying. In a study by Ghent University, potatoes stored at 4 °C formed more acrylamide than those stored at 8 °C.

Are grilled sausages particularly problematic?

Sausages count as processed meat, which the IARC classifies as carcinogenic, mainly because of bowel cancer. According to the IARC, the risk of bowel cancer rises by about 18 percent for every 50 grams a day. This refers to regular consumption, not to a single barbecue party. When grilling, there is one more rule: don't let them char.

How much acrylamide is safe?

A safe lower limit cannot be given. Because acrylamide can damage DNA, EFSA has not set a tolerable daily intake. The principle is to keep intake as low as reasonably achievable.

Are children and pregnant women more affected?

Relative to their body weight, children take in the most acrylamide. According to the BfR, acrylamide can cross the placenta and pass into breast milk. For pregnant and breastfeeding women and for families with children, aiming for golden rather than charred is therefore especially worthwhile.

Further reading

SJ
Shukri Jarmoukli
Physician, Integrative Medicine · ViveCura Berlin

Licensed physician with a focus on integrative medicine and clinical psychoneuroimmunology. He combines conventional medical diagnostics with lifestyle, nutrition and environmental medicine. When it comes to detoxification, he first looks at which exposures can be avoided in everyday life.

Skalitzer Straße 137, 10999 Berlin

Sources

  1. Viegas O, Yebra-Pimentel I, Martínez-Carballo E, Simal-Gandara J, Ferreira IMPLVO. Effect of beer marinades on formation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in charcoal-grilled pork. J Agric Food Chem. 2014;62(12):2638-2643. DOI: 10.1021/jf404966w [In vitro, grilling experiment with pork over charcoal]
  2. Lee JG, Kim SY, Moon JS et al. Effects of grilling procedures on levels of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in grilled meats. Food Chem. 2016;199:632-638. DOI: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2015.12.017 [In vitro, grilling experiments with meat]
  3. Tareke E, Rydberg P, Karlsson P et al. Analysis of acrylamide, a carcinogen formed in heated foodstuffs. J Agric Food Chem. 2002;50(17):4998-5006. DOI: 10.1021/jf020302f [In vitro, measurements in heated foods]
  4. Mottram DS, Wedzicha BL, Dodson AT. Acrylamide is formed in the Maillard reaction. Nature. 2002;419(6906):448-449. DOI: 10.1038/419448a [In vitro, model experiments on the Maillard reaction]
  5. Stadler RH, Blank I, Varga N et al. Acrylamide from Maillard reaction products. Nature. 2002;419(6906):449-450. DOI: 10.1038/419449a [In vitro, model experiments on the Maillard reaction]
  6. Smith JS, Ameri F, Gadgil P. Effect of marinades on the formation of heterocyclic amines in grilled beef steaks. J Food Sci. 2008;73(6):T100-T105. DOI: 10.1111/j.1750-3841.2008.00856.x [In vitro, grilling experiments with beef steaks]
  7. Salmon CP, Knize MG, Felton JS. Effects of marinating on heterocyclic amine carcinogen formation in grilled chicken. Food Chem Toxicol. 1997;35(5):433-441. DOI: 10.1016/s0278-6915(97)00020-3 [In vitro, grilling experiments with chicken]
  8. Felton JS, Fultz E, Dolbeare FA, Knize MG. Effect of microwave pretreatment on heterocyclic aromatic amine mutagens/carcinogens in fried beef patties. Food Chem Toxicol. 1994;32(10):897-903. DOI: 10.1016/0278-6915(94)90087-6 [In vitro, frying experiments with beef patties]
  9. Salmon CP, Knize MG, Panteleakos FN et al. Minimization of heterocyclic amines and thermal inactivation of Escherichia coli in fried ground beef. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2000;92(21):1773-1778. DOI: 10.1093/jnci/92.21.1773 [In vitro, frying experiments with minced beef patties]
  10. De Wilde T, De Meulenaer B, Mestdagh F et al. Influence of storage practices on acrylamide formation during potato frying. J Agric Food Chem. 2005;53(16):6550-6557. DOI: 10.1021/jf050650s [In vitro, storage experiment with potatoes]
  11. Rothman N, Poirier MC, Baser ME et al. Formation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon-DNA adducts in peripheral white blood cells during consumption of charcoal-broiled beef. Carcinogenesis. 1990;11(7):1241-1243. DOI: 10.1093/carcin/11.7.1241 [In vivo, human study with 4 participants]
  12. Ghanayem BI, McDaniel LP, Churchwell MI et al. Role of CYP2E1 in the epoxidation of acrylamide to glycidamide and formation of DNA and hemoglobin adducts. Toxicol Sci. 2005;88(2):311-318. DOI: 10.1093/toxsci/kfi307 [In vivo, animal study in mice]
  13. Pelucchi C, Bosetti C, Galeone C, La Vecchia C. Dietary acrylamide and cancer risk: an updated meta-analysis. Int J Cancer. 2015;136(12):2912-2922. DOI: 10.1002/ijc.29339 [Meta-analysis of observational studies]
  14. Bouvard V, Loomis D, Guyton KZ et al. Carcinogenicity of consumption of red and processed meat. Lancet Oncol. 2015;16(16):1599-1600. DOI: 10.1016/S1470-2045(15)00444-1 [Authority document, evaluation by the IARC working group]
  15. EFSA Panel on Contaminants in the Food Chain (CONTAM). Scientific Opinion on acrylamide in food. EFSA J. 2015;13(6):4104. DOI: 10.2903/j.efsa.2015.4104 [Authority document, EFSA scientific opinion]
  16. Benford D, Bignami M, Chipman JK et al. Assessment of the genotoxicity of acrylamide. EFSA J. 2022;20(5):e07293. DOI: 10.2903/j.efsa.2022.7293 [Authority document, EFSA statement on genotoxicity]
  17. Bundesinstitut für Risikobewertung. Vergolden statt verkohlen: Fragen und Antworten zu Acrylamid in Lebensmitteln. Stand 26.08.2024. Online: bfr.bund.de [Authority document, BfR questions and answers]
  18. Europäische Behörde für Lebensmittelsicherheit (EFSA). Themenseite Acrylamide. Online: efsa.europa.eu [Authority document, EFSA topic page]
  19. International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). Q&A on the carcinogenicity of the consumption of red meat and processed meat. 2015. Online: iarc.who.int [Authority document, IARC questions and answers]
  20. National Cancer Institute. Chemicals in Meat Cooked at High Temperatures and Cancer Risk. Stand 11.07.2017. Online: cancer.gov [Authority document, National Cancer Institute fact sheet]

How to weigh the evidence: All studies were checked via PubMed or DOI resolution against title, authors, year and journal. Figures on study results come from the respective abstracts. Temperatures, intake levels and official assessments come from publications by the BfR, EFSA, IARC and NCI.

It is well established that acrylamide, HCAs and PAHs form during high-heat cooking and that potatoes stored in the cold form more sugar. It is equally well established that acrylamide can damage DNA in animal studies. The data on marinades, grill trays, turning and pre-cooking, on the other hand, come mainly from lab experiments. They show how much of these substances forms in food, not how much of it reaches the body. How large the cancer risk from dietary acrylamide is in humans remains open.

This article is for information only and does not replace medical advice. It does not contain any recommendation for specific products or brands.

Have questions or want to book an appointment?

We'd be happy to advise you personally at our practice.

Book appointment