Nutrition guide · Plant-based and animal-based compared

Plant-based or animal-based? Why the honest answer is neither vegan nor steak

Both camps have good arguments and blind spots. Here you'll learn what studies show on iron, B12, omega-3, iodine and creatine. And how you can close the gaps on both sides.

SJ
Shukri Jarmoukli · Physician, Integrative Medicine · ViveCura Berlin
23 sources with DOIKPNI perspectiveIron, B12, omega-3, iodine, creatineReading time approx. 25 minutes
My starting point

I don't ask which camp you belong to. I ask what reaches your cells.

Plants and animals provide different building blocks. Both extremes have gaps. You can measure many of them and close them in a targeted way.

One camp says: plants are the future, meat is harmful. The other camp says: without meat, you're missing the most important things. And you're standing in between with your shopping basket.

Maybe you've been eating plant-based for years and still feel exhausted all the time. Maybe you enjoy eating meat and worry about your heart or your gut. Neither is usually a lack of discipline. More often, a building block is missing that you can't see.

In this article, I'd like to show you a different perspective. For me, the debate is not a war of beliefs. It's a question of nutrient supply.

The key word for this is bioavailability. Imagine a parcel delivery. You order ten parcels, but only six arrive. The nutrition table counts the order. Your body lives on the delivery.

In my practice, I meet both camps. People on a vegan diet with empty iron stores. And people who eat a lot of meat and have hardly any fiber on their plate.

From the perspective of KPNI, Clinical Psychoneuroimmunology, a good answer could look like this. Plant-forward, with targeted building blocks where plants fall short. KPNI views the nervous system, immune system, hormones and metabolism like an orchestra. If one instrument is missing, the whole piece sounds different.

This is not a lukewarm compromise. It's a way to close the gaps of both extremes without giving up your values. Whether you eat vegan out of conviction or enjoy eating meat.

What to expect here

  • Why both camps have good arguments
  • What bioavailability means
  • Iron: stores, ferritin and thresholds
  • When an iron infusion can be an option
  • Vitamin B12 and the right lab values
  • Omega-3: EPA, DHA and algae oil
  • Iodine, calcium and your bones
  • Creatine for brain and muscles
  • What is often missing when you eat a lot of meat
  • The KPNI view of four systems
  • Three levers for your everyday life
  • Answers to 14 common questions
Controlled randomized or controlled study in humans, including reviews of such studiesObservational cohort, cross-sectional study, review or official document: shows associations, not causes

Two camps, one better question

What you eat is more than a list of nutrients. It's about animal welfare, the climate, family and identity. That's why every discussion about it gets personal so quickly.

I respect both sides. People who eat vegan often have well-considered ethical reasons. People who eat meat often value tradition and nutrient-dense foods. Both choices deserve respect.

Still, a sober look is worthwhile. Your cells don't ask about your convictions. They ask for iron, B12, iodine and the right fatty acids.

I know this pattern very well.

Context: A woman has eaten a vegan diet for years, out of deep conviction. She cooks fresh and eats lots of vegetables, legumes and whole grains. On paper, her diet is exemplary.

Problem: For months, she has been exhausted and has trouble concentrating. An earlier blood count was unremarkable.

Findings: On closer inspection, her iron stores are empty. Her B12 markers are abnormal. On top of that come heavy periods and a rather low protein intake.

Turning point: She stays vegan. We add a reliable B12 source and medically supervised iron replenishment. She combines iron-rich meals with vitamin C and has her bleeding checked by a gynecologist.

Outcome: After a few months, she reports noticeably more energy. Her follow-up values are better. I can't claim causality, but I document the temporal association.

Lesson: The problem was not her way of eating, but her nutrient supply.

She didn't have to choose between conviction and health. You probably don't have to either.

A large review shows how common such gaps are on both sides.

Observational Nutrient gaps in all dietary patterns [Systematic review, 141 studies]

A team from Wageningen in the Netherlands evaluated 141 studies. It compared the nutrient supply of adults on a plant-based diet with that of people who eat meat.

People on a plant-based diet took in more fiber, folate, magnesium and vitamins C and E. For B12, vitamin D, iron, zinc, iodine and calcium, intake and status were mostly lower. The intake of EPA and DHA was also lower.

People on a vegan diet had the lowest intake of B12, calcium and iodine, as well as lower bone density. Meat eaters, in turn, risked getting too little fiber, folate, magnesium, calcium, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and vitamins D and E. Protein was lower on a plant-based diet, but well within the recommended range.

The team's conclusion: nutrient gaps existed in all dietary patterns, vegan, vegetarian and meat-heavy.

What this means for you: No dietary pattern automatically covers everything. Each has its own typical gaps.

The authors were working at Unilever when the review was published; more on this in the transparency section at the end.

Neufingerl N, Eilander A. Nutrients. 2021;14(1):29. DOI: 10.3390/nu14010029 · PMID: 35010904
Another perspective

The question “vegan or meat?” divides people into camps. The question “What reaches me, and what am I missing right now?” gets you further. It is more honest, and you can answer it step by step.

A first step can be very simple. For three days, write down what you eat, without changing anything. Then ask yourself four questions. Where does my B12 come from? Where does my iron come from? Where does my iodine come from? And how much protein lands on my plate?

I explain in detail how much protein you need in the article How much protein do you really need.

And now you know why the better question is not which camp is right, but what reaches your cells.

Bioavailability: what's on your plate and what arrives

Maybe you know this. Your nutrition app shows green checkmarks everywhere. Iron reached, zinc reached, everything on track. And yet your blood shows gaps.

That's not a contradiction. The app calculates with what you eat. Your body calculates with what it absorbs.

With iron, this difference becomes especially clear. Animal foods mainly provide heme iron. Think of it as a passenger with their own entrance. It uses its own absorption pathway in the gut and is hardly disturbed by other substances in the meal.

Plant iron is non-heme iron. It waits in line at the main entrance. Other substances in the meal help decide whether it gets in or is pushed aside.

Observational How much iron arrives from a diet [Review]

Hurrell and Egli from ETH Zurich summarized the evidence on iron absorption. In people without iron reserves, 14 to 18 percent of the iron from a mixed diet was absorbed. From a vegetarian diet, it was 5 to 12 percent.

Even more important than the composition of the diet was a person's own iron status. Empty stores open the door wider, full stores put on the brakes. According to the authors, exactly how meat influences the absorption of plant iron, the so-called meat factor, is still open.

What this means for you: The amount of iron on the package reveals little about your blood. Your store levels and your meal help decide.

Hurrell R, Egli I. Am J Clin Nutr. 2010;91(5):1461S-1467S. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.2010.28674F · PMID: 20200263
Controlled Phytate slows, vitamin C compensates [Controlled absorption study in humans]

A team at the University of Gothenburg gave participants wheat rolls with labeled iron on alternating days. Sometimes without phytate, sometimes with increasing amounts of it. This made it possible to measure exactly how much iron arrived.

Just 2 mg of phytate phosphorus reduced iron absorption by 18 percent. At 25 mg, it was 64 percent, and at 250 mg, as much as 82 percent. Phytate behaves like a magnet that holds on to iron.

Additional vitamin C was able to markedly counteract this inhibition. The effect of meat was less clear and only showed at the highest amount of phytate.

What this means for you: Vitamin C in the same meal is a simple lever for plant iron.

Hallberg L, Brune M, Rossander L. Am J Clin Nutr. 1989;49(1):140-4. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/49.1.140 · PMID: 2911999

Putting this in context matters. In single-meal studies, such effects are pronounced. Across a varied diet, according to Hurrell and Egli, they are smaller.

Phytate is not an enemy. It's found in valuable foods such as legumes, whole grains and nuts. You don't have to avoid it. You can balance it out cleverly.

How to absorb more plant iron

  • Add vitamin C: Bell pepper, broccoli, citrus fruits or berries in the same meal can improve the absorption of plant iron.
  • Coffee and black tea apart from meals: Their polyphenols can slow iron absorption. It's better to drink them between meals.
  • Soaking, sprouting, sourdough: Mechanistically plausible, human studies still thin: These methods can break down phytate. How much this increases iron absorption in everyday life has been little studied in humans.
  • Calcium separately: Calcium can also slow iron absorption. So it's better not to take a calcium supplement with your most iron-rich meal.
  • Variety: Legumes, whole grains, nuts, seeds and green vegetables together provide more than any single food.
Another perspective

A plate is a team. No single food decides alone. For your gut, lentils with bell pepper are a different meal than lentils with a cup of black tea. The amount of iron is the same, the delivery is not.

And now you know why a nutrition table only tells half the story.

Iron: unremarkable blood count, empty stores

You sleep enough and are still tired. When you exercise, you lack strength. Your concentration fades. And then you hear: your blood count is unremarkable.

That may be true. And yet your iron stores can be almost empty.

Imagine your iron as a household. The hemoglobin in your blood count is the food on the table. Ferritin shows you what is still in the pantry.

Your body keeps the table set for as long as possible. That's why the pantry empties first. Only when it is almost empty does hemoglobin drop as well.

So an unremarkable blood count can hide an empty pantry. This affects people on a plant-based diet more often.

Observational Vegetarian diet and iron stores [Meta-analysis, 24 studies]

A team at the Medical University of Vienna summarized studies on ferritin in adults on a vegetarian diet. The meta-analysis included 24 cross-sectional studies.

On average, people on a vegetarian diet had a ferritin level 29.7 µg/l lower than comparison groups who ate meat. In men, the difference was 61.9 µg/l. In women before menopause, it was 17.7 µg/l.

At the same time, the team emphasizes that high iron stores are also a risk factor, for example for type 2 diabetes. It therefore recommends that both groups have their iron status checked regularly.

What this means for you: Low stores are more common on a plant-based diet. But very full stores are not a goal either. Measuring is better than guessing.

Haider LM, Schwingshackl L, Hoffmann G, Ekmekcioglu C. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2018;58(8):1359-1374. DOI: 10.1080/10408398.2016.1259210 · PMID: 27880062
5 to 12%Iron that arrives from a vegetarian diet when stores are empty
14 to 18%Iron that arrives from a mixed diet when stores are empty
≈ 25 µg/lFerritin threshold for iron deficiency in women in a large US analysis (1 µg/l = 1 ng/ml)

But at what level is a store actually empty? Experts are still debating this.

Observational Where iron deficiency begins physiologically [Real-world, NHANES cross-sectional study]

The WHO defines iron deficiency in women as a ferritin below 15 µg/l. In children, the threshold is 12 µg/l. According to the authors, these thresholds are based on expert opinion.

A team at the US health agency CDC therefore analyzed data from 7,498 non-pregnant women aged 15 to 49. Data from 2,569 young children were added.

The team looked for the ferritin level at which blood formation shows the first signs of iron deficiency. Hemoglobin and the soluble transferrin receptor served as markers. People with signs of inflammation were excluded beforehand.

In women, the threshold was about 25 µg/l, in children about 20 µg/l.

What this means for you: A ferritin just above the lab's lower limit does not automatically mean that your stores are well filled.

Mei Z, Addo OY, Jefferds ME, Sharma AJ, Flores-Ayala RC, Brittenham GM. Lancet Haematol. 2021;8(8):e572-e582. DOI: 10.1016/S2352-3026(21)00168-X · PMID: 34329578

It gets interesting when you ask whether low stores can cause symptoms even without anemia. Two controlled studies from Switzerland and France looked at this.

Controlled Iron tablets for fatigue without anemia [RCT, n=198]

In 44 general practices in France, 198 women aged 18 to 53 took part. All of them were tired, had no anemia and had a ferritin below 50 µg/l.

For twelve weeks, 102 women received 80 mg of iron daily, and 96 received a placebo. With iron, the fatigue score on a psychological scale fell by 47.7 percent. On placebo, it fell by 28.8 percent.

Compared with placebo, ferritin rose by 11.4 µg/l. There was no significant effect on quality of life, depression or anxiety.

What this means for you: Even without anemia, a low ferritin can be linked to fatigue. The study team recommends considering iron for unexplained fatigue with a ferritin below 50 µg/l.

Vaucher P, Druais PL, Waldvogel S, Favrat B. CMAJ. 2012;184(11):1247-54. DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.110950 · PMID: 22777991
Controlled Iron infusion for fatigue without anemia [RCT, n=90]

At the University Hospital Zurich, 90 tired women before menopause received either 800 mg of iron as an infusion or a placebo. None had anemia, and all had a ferritin of no more than 50 ng/ml. Neither the women nor the treatment team knew who received what.

Across all women, the difference narrowly missed statistical significance. With a ferritin of no more than 15 ng/ml, the picture was clearer. Here, 82 percent of the iron group reported less fatigue, compared with 47 percent on placebo.

Side effects occurred in 21 percent of the iron group and in 7 percent on placebo. None of them were serious.

What this means for you: Women with very empty stores benefited most clearly. An infusion therefore needs a clear indication.

Krayenbuehl PA, Battegay E, Breymann C, Furrer J, Schulthess G. Blood. 2011;118(12):3222-7. DOI: 10.1182/blood-2011-04-346304 · PMID: 21705493
Review Iron deficiency from a hematology perspective [Review]

An international team led by Pasricha from Melbourne summarized the current knowledge on iron deficiency. One important message: symptoms and functional limitations can occur even without anemia.

The hormone hepcidin plays a key role. Imagine it as a bouncer at your gut. During inflammation and after high-dose iron tablets, it lets less iron in.

According to the review, iron tablets are the first choice in most cases. In the team's assessment, modern infusions can replenish the missing stores quickly, safely and in full.

In every case of iron deficiency, the cause should also be investigated. Testing for celiac disease should be routinely considered.

What this means for you: Iron is not a do-it-yourself topic. Cause, form and dose belong in a medical assessment.

Pasricha SR, Tye-Din J, Muckenthaler MU, Swinkels DW. Lancet. 2021;397(10270):233-248. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(20)32594-0 · PMID: 33285139

Clinically, I observe that many people only feel truly at their best with a ferritin above roughly 100 ng/ml. This is a guide from my practice, not a study threshold. The studies above set their thresholds considerably lower.

For me, this means: I take functional iron deficiency seriously. By this, I mean symptoms that fit low stores, even when the blood count is still unremarkable.

Important about ferritin

Ferritin rises during inflammation, even when the stores are actually low. That's why an inflammation marker such as CRP always belongs with it. You can read more about this in the article on silent inflammation and hs-CRP.

Too much iron is not harmless either. Never take high-dose iron on a hunch. Have your levels measured first and the cause clarified.

If tablets are not enough, are not tolerated, or inflammation is slowing absorption, an iron infusion can be a good option. The prerequisite is that it is done correctly: with a clear indication, medical supervision and a follow-up check afterwards.

A smart approach to iron

  • Measure: Ferritin together with CRP and a blood count, and transferrin saturation if needed.
  • Combine: Eat plant iron with vitamin C, and drink coffee and black tea apart from your meals.
  • Clarify the cause: Heavy periods, celiac disease or other losses should be assessed by a doctor.
  • Follow up: The team behind the French study suggests checking the effect of iron supplementation with a blood test after six weeks.

I explain in detail why spinach is overrated as a source of iron in the article on iron, ferritin and spinach.

Another perspective

A low ferritin is not a verdict on your way of eating. It is a piece of information. It shows you where you can adjust without switching camps.

And now you know why an unremarkable blood count does not automatically mean full iron stores.

Vitamin B12: the building block plants don't provide

Tingling in your hands or feet. You forget appointments that you would normally never miss. On top of that, a fatigue that doesn't match any lack of sleep. This is how a B12 deficiency can make itself felt.

The tricky part: your liver builds up a B12 reserve that often lasts several years. A deficiency can therefore develop slowly and go unnoticed for a long time.

Neither plants nor animals produce B12 themselves. It comes from microorganisms. Animals take it up and store it in meat, liver, eggs and milk. Plants, on the other hand, do not provide reliable B12.

That makes B12 the building block for which a vegan diet most clearly needs a supplement. The numbers show this too.

Observational B12 in men on a mixed, vegetarian and vegan diet [Cohort, cross-sectional analysis, n=689]

A team at the University of Oxford studied 689 men from the EPIC-Oxford cohort. Of these, 226 ate a mixed diet, 231 a vegetarian diet and 232 a vegan diet.

The mean serum B12 level was 281 pmol/l on a mixed diet. On a vegetarian diet, it was 182 pmol/l, and on a vegan diet, 122 pmol/l.

A level below 118 pmol/l was considered a deficiency. This applied to 52 percent of the vegan men, 7 percent of the vegetarian men and a single man on a mixed diet.

Neither age nor how long the men had followed their diet was significantly associated with their B12 level. Folate showed the opposite picture: here, the vegan men had the highest levels.

What this means for you: Every dietary pattern has its strengths and gaps. On a vegan diet, roughly every second man here had a B12 deficiency. So don't rely on your stores still being enough.

Gilsing AM, Crowe FL, Lloyd-Wright Z, Sanders TA, Appleby PN, Allen NE, Key TJ. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2010;64(9):933-9. DOI: 10.1038/ejcn.2010.142 · PMID: 20648045
Review How common B12 deficiency is on a vegetarian diet [Review, 18 studies]

A team at East Carolina University in the US evaluated 18 studies. Only studies that had assessed deficiency using methylmalonic acid, holotranscobalamin or both were included.

In pregnant women, the deficiency rate was 62 percent. In children, it was 25 to almost 86 percent, and in adolescents 21 to 41 percent. In older people, the range was 11 to 90 percent.

Deficiency was more common on a vegan diet than on a vegetarian one. And it was more common in people who had been vegetarian since birth than in those who had switched later.

The team's conclusion: deficiency occurred regardless of age, place of residence or type of vegetarian diet. It recommends preventive measures, including the regular use of supplements containing B12.

What this means for you: Especially during pregnancy, in childhood and in older age, it's worth taking a close look at B12.

Pawlak R, Parrott SJ, Raj S, Cullum-Dugan D, Lucus D. Nutr Rev. 2013;71(2):110-7. DOI: 10.1111/nure.12001 · PMID: 23356638

But there is another side too. A Berlin study shows how well a vegan diet can do on B12 when the supplementation is right.

Observational Vegan in Germany: the Berlin RBVD study [Real-world, cross-sectional study, n=72]

A team at the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment in Berlin compared 36 people on a vegan diet with 36 people on a mixed diet. Each group consisted of 18 women and 18 men aged 30 to 60.

Almost everyone in the vegan group had taken dietary supplements in the previous four weeks. In the mixed-diet group, it was one third.

For B12, the blood markers showed no difference between the groups. This was despite the vegan group taking in hardly any B12 from food. According to the team, this could be due to the high rate of supplement use.

There was also no group difference in iron status. Ferritin and blood count pointed to iron deficiency in four people on a vegan diet and in three people not on a vegan diet.

Iodine stood out. In one third of the people on a vegan diet, the iodine level in 24-hour urine was below 20 µg/l. That is the WHO threshold for severe iodine deficiency.

What this means for you: A well-planned vegan diet with supplements can do well on B12. Iodine deserves its own attention here.

Weikert C, Trefflich I, Menzel J, Obeid R, Longree A, Dierkes J, Meyer K, Herter-Aeberli I, Mai K, Stangl GI, Müller SM, Schwerdtle T, Lampen A, Abraham K. Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2020;117(35-36):575-582. DOI: 10.3238/arztebl.2020.0575 · PMID: 33161940

To assess your B12 status correctly, it's worth looking at the right lab values. Imagine your B12 as your money.

Lab valueAnalogyWhat it shows
Serum B12Bank balanceThe total amount in the blood, including the part your cells can hardly use
Holotranscobalamin (holoTC)WalletThe share that is bound to its transport protein and reaches your cells
Methylmalonic acid (MMA)Smoke detectorRises when your cells lack B12. With weak kidney function, it can also rise for other reasons

A serum B12 in the lower normal range can therefore be misleading. Holotranscobalamin and methylmalonic acid can show more precisely how well your cells are supplied. For the woman in the story at the beginning, the B12 markers were abnormal.

Covering B12 reliably

  • Reliable source: On a vegan diet, a B12 supplement or fortified foods. A deficiency can also develop on a vegetarian diet.
  • No shaky sources: Algae and fermented foods are not considered reliable B12 sources.
  • Measure correctly: Holotranscobalamin or methylmalonic acid, not just serum B12.
  • Look early: Be especially careful before and during pregnancy and with children.
  • Dose appropriately: Which form and amount suit you is best clarified with a doctor.

You can read how to plan a vegan diet well overall in the article on the opportunities and limits of a vegan diet.

Another perspective

A B12 supplement is not an admission that vegan doesn't work. Animals also get their B12 from microorganisms. And the B12 in supplements is also produced with the help of microorganisms. You're simply taking a shortcut to the source.

And now you know why B12 is not a question of belief, but a question of the source.

Omega-3: why flaxseed oil alone is often not enough

In the morning, you add flaxseed oil to your muesli and sprinkle walnuts over your salad. That's a good thing to do for yourself. It's just that less EPA and DHA often arrives than you think.

Plants mainly provide ALA, the starting form of omega-3 fatty acids. Your body can build EPA and DHA from it. But this conversion is like single-lane roadworks. Only a little gets through.

On top of that, linoleic acid crowds onto the same roadworks. This omega-6 fatty acid is found in abundance in many plant oils. Both use the same enzymes. I explain how the three omega-3 fatty acids are connected in the article on ALA, EPA and DHA.

Observational Omega-3 in the blood on a meat-based, vegetarian and vegan diet [Cohort, cross-sectional analysis, n=659]

A team at the University of Oxford measured the fatty acids in the blood plasma of 659 men from the UK. Of these, 196 ate meat, 231 ate a vegetarian diet and 232 a vegan diet.

EPA and DHA were lower on a vegetarian and vegan diet than on a meat-based diet. For the intermediate stage DPA, there were only small differences.

Surprisingly, the levels did not depend significantly on how long the men had been eating this way. The range went from less than one year to more than 20 years.

In the vegetarian and vegan men, there was another pattern: the higher the share of linoleic acid in the blood, the lower DHA tended to be.

The team concludes: when animal foods are missing entirely, the body produces EPA and DHA itself. The levels in the blood then stay low, but stable.

What this means for you: Your body does not go into free fall. But it settles at a low level. A blood test can show whether that is enough for you.

Rosell MS, Lloyd-Wright Z, Appleby PN, Sanders TA, Allen NE, Key TJ. Am J Clin Nutr. 2005;82(2):327-34. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn.82.2.327 · PMID: 16087975

The omega-3 index shows how well you are supplied. It measures the share of EPA and DHA in the membranes of your red blood cells. Think of it as a fill level that reflects the past few months.

Observational Omega-3 index on a vegan diet and algae oil [Cohort, open-label supplementation without control group, n=165]

A US team measured the omega-3 index of 165 people who had been on a vegan diet for many years. On average, it was 3.7 percent.

This was similar to a group of US soldiers on a mixed diet who also took in hardly any EPA and DHA. Women had slightly higher levels than men, and the value rose with age.

For four months, 46 people with an index below 4 percent received 254 mg of EPA and DHA from algae daily. Their index rose from 3.1 to 4.8 percent.

There was no control group. One of the authors is affiliated with OmegaQuant, a provider of the omega-3 index test.

What this means for you: Even a small amount of EPA and DHA from algae was associated with a markedly higher index. A follow-up measurement shows whether this gets you to your target.

Sarter B, Kelsey KS, Schwartz TA, Harris WS. Clin Nutr. 2015;34(2):212-8. DOI: 10.1016/j.clnu.2014.03.003 · PMID: 24679552

For EPA and DHA, two options are therefore worth considering: an omega-3 oil with EPA or an algae oil. If you eat vegan, algae oil is the suitable choice.

Clinical tradition without a strong study base: In my practice, I recommend omega-3 as an oil, not as capsules. An oil can be dosed finely. And you can check its freshness by its smell and taste. Kept cool and tightly sealed, it stays fresh longer.

The right amount depends on your starting level. A measurement beforehand and another after a few months show you whether you are reaching your target.

Clarify beforehand

Do you take blood-thinning medication, or do you have surgery coming up? Then discuss higher amounts of omega-3 with a doctor beforehand.

You can read what the studies show overall about plant, animal and algae sources in the article Omega-3 from plants, animals or algae.

Another perspective

EPA and DHA originally come from microalgae. From there, they travel through the food chain. With algae oil, you start right at the beginning of this chain.

And now you know why flaxseed oil alone is often not enough for EPA and DHA.

Iodine, calcium and your bones: the quiet construction sites

Iodine and bones stay quiet for a long time. You often don't notice a low iodine supply right away. And bones often only make themselves felt when they break.

That's exactly why an early look is worthwhile here. On a very plant-based diet, both construction sites can quietly run in the background.

Iodine: the material for your timekeeper

Your thyroid is the timekeeper of your metabolism. For its hormones, it needs iodine as building material. If iodine is missing, it can produce fewer hormones.

Plant foods usually provide little iodine. On a mixed diet, dairy products and eggs contribute to the supply. A simple source for everyone is iodized salt.

Review Iodine on a vegan, vegetarian and mixed diet [Systematic review, 15 studies]

A team at the University of Nottingham evaluated 15 studies from industrialized countries. Together, they contained data from 127,094 adults.

Groups on a vegan diet had the lowest urinary iodine levels, followed by groups on a vegetarian diet. Neither reached an optimal iodine status.

People on a mixed diet had the highest iodine intake in 83 percent of the studies.

But there was also the other extreme. The highest iodine intake of all groups was measured in women on a vegan diet. On a vegan diet with excessive iodine, a large part came from seaweed.

What this means for you: On a plant-based diet, iodine can easily run low. With seaweed, it can also become too much. So you need a source that is easy to dose.

Eveleigh ER, Coneyworth LJ, Avery A, Welham SJM. Nutrients. 2020;12(6):1606. DOI: 10.3390/nu12061606 · PMID: 32486114

The Berlin study from the B12 section fits this picture. There, urinary iodine was below the WHO threshold for severe deficiency in one third of the people on a vegan diet.

Bones: a permanent construction site

Your bone is not a finished wall. It is a permanent construction site where things are constantly torn down and rebuilt.

New construction needs material such as calcium and protein. Vitamin D is the site manager: it makes sure that calcium gets from your gut into your blood. And weight-bearing exercise is the building order.

83%of studies: highest iodine intake on a mixed diet
2.31Hazard ratio for hip fractures on a vegan diet
14.9additional hip fractures per 1,000 people over ten years
Observational Bone fractures by diet in EPIC-Oxford [Cohort, n=54,898]

A team at the University of Oxford followed almost 55,000 people for an average of 17.6 years. Among them were 29,380 people who ate meat, 15,499 on a vegetarian diet and 1,982 on a vegan diet.

A brief term first: the hazard ratio compares how often an event occurs over time in two groups. A value of 1 means equally often, a value of 2 twice as often.

On a vegan diet, the hazard ratio for hip fractures was 2.31. This corresponds to 14.9 additional hip fractures per 1,000 people over ten years. On a vegetarian diet, the value was 1.25, which means 2.9 additional cases.

People on a vegan diet also had more fractures overall (1.43) and more leg fractures (2.05). For the wrist and ankle, there was no significant difference.

The associations became somewhat weaker, but persisted, when the team took dietary calcium and protein into account. The team concludes that bone health on a vegan diet needs further research.

What this means for you: This is an observational study, and an association does not prove a cause. Still, on a vegan diet, it's worth paying targeted attention to your bones.

Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Armstrong MEG, Fensom GK, Knuppel A, Papier K, Perez-Cornago A, Travis RC, Key TJ. BMC Med. 2020;18(1):353. DOI: 10.1186/s12916-020-01815-3 · PMID: 33222682

A large review shows that both sides belong to the picture: opportunities and risks.

Review Vegan diet: benefits and risks in the overall picture [Systematic review, umbrella review]

A team from Prague and Düsseldorf collected meta-analyses on the vegan diet and recalculated them. It rated the certainty of the evidence using the GRADE system.

In healthy adults, a vegan diet reduced body weight by an average of 2.52 kg in eight RCTs. The certainty of evidence for this was moderate.

Further advantages showed up with low certainty of evidence: a 16 percent lower cancer risk and lower ApoB levels. ApoB counts the particles in the blood that transport cholesterol and can enter the vessel wall.

For all-cause mortality, there was only a trend that was not statistically significant.

On the other side was a 46 percent higher risk of bone fractures, also with low certainty of evidence.

The team's conclusion: a vegan diet might benefit the heart and metabolism. But it might also impair bone health.

What this means for you: A vegan diet comes with opportunities and risks. Your task is to use the opportunities and to cushion the risks in a targeted way.

Selinger E, Neuenschwander M, Koller A, Gojda J, Kühn T, Schwingshackl L, Barbaresko J, Schlesinger S. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2023;63(29):9926-9936. DOI: 10.1080/10408398.2022.2075311 · PMID: 37962057

Supplying iodine and your bones

  • Use iodized salt: Use iodized salt instead of regular salt. You don't need more salt for this, just the right kind.
  • Seaweed with caution: The iodine content of seaweed varies widely. Some types provide far too much iodine.
  • Keep your thyroid in mind: If you have a thyroid condition, discuss iodine supplements with a doctor beforehand.
  • Plan in calcium: Good sources are fortified plant-based drinks, calcium-rich mineral water, kale, broccoli, sesame and tofu made with calcium sulfate.
  • Measure vitamin D: The site manager shouldn't be missing. A blood test shows you where you stand.
  • Challenge your bones: Strength training gives your bones the order to rebuild.

I look at the role dairy products play in this in the article on dairy products and your health.

Another perspective

These numbers are not a verdict on a vegan diet. They show you on which construction site material might be missing. And because bones constantly renew themselves, you can start supplying better material at any time.

And now you know why iodine and bones deserve their own attention on a plant-based diet.

Creatine for brain and muscles: more than a sports powder

Maybe you associate creatine with the gym and big tubs of powder. But it's about something more fundamental: energy in your cells.

Every cell pays for its work with ATP, its energy currency. Together with phosphate, creatine forms phosphocreatine. This is a fast-charging reserve that quickly recharges used ATP.

Your muscles use this reserve, and so does your brain. Your body produces part of its creatine itself. The rest comes from food, especially meat.

On a vegetarian diet, creatine stores in the muscle are therefore lower. The exciting question is: does that make a difference?

Controlled Creatine and cognitive performance on a vegetarian diet [RCT, crossover, n=45]

A team at the University of Sydney gave 45 young adults on a vegetarian diet 5 grams of creatine daily for six weeks. The study was double-blind and placebo-controlled.

In the crossover design, each person received creatine and placebo one after the other. This way, each person served as their own comparison.

On creatine, they performed markedly better in working memory and on an intelligence test. Both tasks require fast processing of information.

What this means for you: If you eat vegetarian, creatine can also play a role in your thinking. However, the study is small and fairly old.

Rae C, Digney AL, McEwan SR, Bates TC. Proc Biol Sci. 2003;270(1529):2147-50. DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2003.2492 · PMID: 14561278
Controlled Creatine in women with and without meat in their diet [RCT, n=128]

A team at Swansea University in Wales studied 128 young women. Some of them ate a vegetarian diet, the others ate meat.

They were randomly assigned, double-blind, to receive 20 grams of creatine or a placebo for five days.

Creatine had no effect on verbal fluency and sustained attention. Memory did improve, however: in the women on a vegetarian diet, not in those who ate meat.

Regardless of diet, reaction times in a choice task varied less on creatine.

What this means for you: On a vegetarian diet, that is, with typically lower stores, a difference in memory was measurable. On a meat-based diet, this advantage did not show.

Benton D, Donohoe R. Br J Nutr. 2011;105(7):1100-5. DOI: 10.1017/S0007114510004733 · PMID: 21118604
Review Creatine on a vegetarian diet at a glance [Systematic review, 9 studies]

A team from Canada summarized nine studies on creatine in vegetarian diets.

Creatine increased the stores in muscle, blood plasma and red blood cells, often above the level seen with a mixed diet. In the brain, however, the phosphocreatine content did not change.

The studies also reported more lean mass, more strength and endurance, and better memory and cognitive performance.

The results were inconsistent on whether people on a vegetarian diet benefit more in sport than people on a mixed diet. The team rated the risk of bias of the studies as moderate to high.

What this means for you: The direction is encouraging, but study quality is limited. Creatine is an option, not a must.

Kaviani M, Shaw K, Chilibeck PD. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17(9):3041. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17093041 · PMID: 32349356

One detail stands out: in the review, phosphocreatine in the brain did not change, yet cognitive performance did in individual studies. How these fit together is still open.

Creatine may be worth considering if you eat vegetarian or vegan. Especially if you exercise. Creatine in supplements is usually produced synthetically and is therefore compatible with a vegan diet.

The studies used 5 grams daily over several weeks, or higher amounts for a short time. Which amount suits you is best clarified with a doctor.

Check first

If you have kidney disease, discuss creatine with a doctor beforehand. Creatine can also raise the lab value creatinine, which is used to assess kidney function. So before a blood test, mention that you take creatine.

Another perspective

Creatine is not a bodybuilder's powder. It is a building block of your energy balance that your body only partly produces itself. On a plant-based diet, it is one of the gaps that are easy to close.

And now you know why creatine is not just a topic for the gym.

The other side: what is often missing when you eat a lot of meat

If you like eating meat, you may have breathed a quick sigh of relief while reading. Iron, B12, creatine: you're covered, right?

Often that's even the case. But a meat-heavy diet has its quiet gaps too. They're just in different places.

The review from the beginning showed it. People who ate a lot of meat risked getting too little fiber, folate, magnesium, calcium, polyunsaturated fatty acids, and vitamins D and E. Let's take a closer look at one of these gaps.

Fiber: fertilizer for your inner garden

Imagine your gut as a garden. The bacteria in it are the plants, fiber is their fertilizer. Without fertilizer, less grows.

Fiber is found only in plant foods: in vegetables, legumes, whole grains, fruit, nuts and seeds. Meat, eggs and cheese provide none.

Supported by large RCTs / meta-analyses: For fiber, the data are unusually broad. A series of meta-analyses evaluated cohort studies and clinical trials together.

Review Fiber and health [Meta-analysis, 185 prospective and 58 clinical studies]

A team at the University of Otago in New Zealand produced this work, with funding from the WHO, among others. It analyzed 185 prospective studies with almost 135 million person-years. In addition, there were 58 clinical trials with 4,635 adults.

In the observational data, the team compared the highest with the lowest fiber intake. With the highest intake, the risk was 15 to 30 percent lower. This applied to all-cause mortality and cardiovascular mortality. It also applied to coronary heart disease, stroke, type 2 diabetes and colorectal cancer.

In the clinical trials, body weight, systolic blood pressure and total cholesterol were statistically significantly lower with more fiber.

The risk dropped most clearly at 25 to 29 grams of fiber a day. The data suggested that higher amounts might bring even more benefit. The team rated the certainty of the evidence for fiber as moderate.

What this means for you: Fiber is not a side detail. Is your plate mostly meat? Then it's worth asking whether you reach 25 grams a day.

Reynolds A, Mann J, Cummings J, Winter N, Mete E, Te Morenga L. Lancet. 2019;393(10170):434-445. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(18)31809-9 · PMID: 30638909

You can read which expectations of fiber the data support, and which they don't, in the article Fiber: what its reputation promises and what the data show.

Processed and red meat

The second question many people who eat meat think about is cancer. Here it's worth taking a close look at what the well-known classification means.

Review Meat and cancer in the IARC assessment [Official document, IARC working group]

A working group of the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) in Lyon assessed the evidence on meat. The IARC is the cancer research agency of the WHO.

Processed meat is salted, cured, fermented or smoked, such as sausage and ham. The working group classified it as carcinogenic to humans. Red meat refers to muscle meat from mammals such as beef, pork and lamb. It is considered probably carcinogenic. The focus was on colorectal cancer.

What matters is what this classification says. It describes how certain the evidence is. It does not say how large the risk is.

What this means for you: Sausage is in the same group as tobacco smoke. But that does not mean both are equally dangerous. Amount and processing play a major role.

Bouvard V, Loomis D, Guyton KZ, Grosse Y, Ghissassi FE, Benbrahim-Tallaa L, Guha N, Mattock H, Straif K. Lancet Oncol. 2015;16(16):1599-600. DOI: 10.1016/S1470-2045(15)00444-1 · PMID: 26514947

I explain why origin and processing make such a difference in the article Meat and cancer: origin and processing.

Heart and blood vessels: two sides of the same cohort

When it comes to the heart, the Oxford cohort shows a picture with two sides.

Observational Heart disease and stroke by diet in EPIC-Oxford [Cohort, n=48,188]

A team at the University of Oxford followed 48,188 people without heart disease or stroke for an average of 18.1 years. Among them were 24,428 people who ate meat and 16,254 on a vegetarian diet, including vegans.

On a vegetarian diet, the hazard ratio for ischemic heart disease was 0.78. This refers to reduced blood flow to the heart. That corresponded to 10 fewer cases per 1,000 people over ten years.

When the team took cholesterol, blood pressure, diabetes and body mass index into account, this difference became smaller.

At the same time, the rate of strokes on a vegetarian diet was 20 percent higher (hazard ratio 1.20). That corresponded to three additional cases per 1,000 people over ten years. Strokes caused by brain bleeds accounted for the largest share.

What this means for you: Here, a vegetarian diet was associated with less heart disease, but with somewhat more strokes. This observational study cannot clarify why that is.

Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Bradbury KE, Perez-Cornago A, Travis RC, Clarke R, Key TJ. BMJ. 2019;366:l4897. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.l4897 · PMID: 31484644

Plant-based is not automatically healthy

Before one camp starts cheering: not all plant-based is the same.

Observational Healthy and less healthy plant-based diets [Cohort, n=209,298]

A team at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health in Boston analyzed three large US cohorts. More than 209,000 women and men were free of chronic diseases at the start. Over a good 4.8 million person-years, 8,631 cases of coronary heart disease occurred.

The team created three scores. The first rewarded plant foods overall. The second rewarded only healthy ones: whole grains, fruit and vegetables, nuts and legumes, oils, and tea and coffee. The third rewarded less healthy ones: juices and sweetened drinks, refined grain products, potatoes and fries, and sweets.

In each case, the ten percent with the highest and the lowest scores were compared. Plant-forward overall was associated with a slightly lower risk (hazard ratio 0.92). With a healthy plant-forward diet, the risk was 25 percent lower (0.75). With many less healthy plant foods, it was 32 percent higher (1.32).

What this means for you: Fries and soda are plant-based too. It's not just whether your plate is plant-based that counts, but which plants are on it.

Satija A, Bhupathiraju SN, Spiegelman D, Chiuve SE, Manson JE, Willett W, Rexrode KM, Rimm EB, Hu FB. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2017;70(4):411-422. DOI: 10.1016/j.jacc.2017.05.047 · PMID: 28728684

What is well established so far: In large analyses, fiber is associated with a lower risk of several common diseases. For processed meat, there is a clear IARC classification. What is still open: why a vegetarian diet in EPIC-Oxford was associated with more brain bleeds. And how much unprocessed meat matters in a fiber-rich diet.

Fair is fair: animal foods have genuine strengths. They provide heme iron, B12, high-quality protein and creatine. Dairy products and eggs also contribute to iodine supply.

Traditional cuisines often used the whole animal. You can read more about this in the article Organ meats, bone broth and the forgotten parts. I explore how to classify an all-meat diet in Carnivore diet: what's behind it.

If you like eating meat

  • Plants first: Fill half your plate with vegetables, legumes or whole grains. The meat becomes the side dish.
  • Count your fiber: For a few days, estimate whether you reach 25 to 29 grams a day.
  • Keep an eye on processing: Reach for sausage and ham less often and for unprocessed meat more often.
  • Nuts and seeds: A handful a day brings magnesium, vitamin E and plant fats to your plate.
  • Measure vitamin D: Intake is often low on a meat-based diet too.

Both extremes compared

The following overview summarizes where the typical gaps lie. It describes tendencies from studies, not a statement about you personally.

Building blockVery plant-basedVery meat-heavyPossible direction
IronStores often lower, phytate slows absorptionUsually better suppliedMeasure ferritin with CRP, vitamin C with meals
Vitamin B12Deficiency common without supplementationUsually well suppliedReliable source, measure holoTC or MMA
EPA and DHALower, but stableUsually higherEPA oil or algae oil, measure omega-3 index
IodineOften too little, with seaweed also too muchUsually better suppliedIodized salt, check status if needed
Calcium and bonesLower intake, more fractures observedCalcium sometimes also lowCalcium sources, vitamin D, strength training
CreatineMuscle stores lowerSupplied through meatSupplementation may be worth considering
FiberUsually plentifulOften too littleVegetables, legumes, whole grains, nuts
Folate, magnesium, vitamin E, ALAUsually plentifulMore often lowMore plant variety
Vitamin DOften lowOften lowMeasure
ProteinLower, usually within the recommended rangePlentifulLegumes, soy, depending on diet eggs or dairy
Another perspective

If you eat a lot of meat, you don't need less attention than someone who eats vegan. Just in different places. And often the gaps of one side are the strengths of the other.

And now you know why a meat-heavy diet has its own gaps too.

The KPNI view of four systems

Maybe you know this. You sleep enough and are still tired. You forget appointments, catch colds more often and get cold faster than others.

Your first blood tests are unremarkable. And you wonder whether you're just imagining it all.

Remember the orchestra from the beginning? KPNI sees the nervous system, immune system, metabolism and hormones as musicians who are constantly playing together. Nutrients are their instruments. If one is missing, it's not just one musician playing more quietly. The whole piece sounds different.

That's why gaps rarely show up in just one place. A single building block can be missing in several systems at once.

Nervous system: material for messengers and wiring

Your brain makes dopamine, a messenger for drive and motivation. The enzyme for the first step of this production needs iron.

Your body needs B12 for the myelin sheaths. That's the insulating layer around your nerve fibers, similar to the coating of a cable. DHA is an important building block of the cell membranes in your brain. And creatine serves your nerve cells as a fast energy store.

From a KPNI perspective, this could explain why fatigue, concentration problems and lack of drive often occur together. The creatine studies above fit this picture.

You can read how micronutrients power your energy metabolism in the article Micronutrients as cofactors of your energy metabolism. You can read whether a vegetarian diet is linked to mood in Vegetarian diet and depression.

Immune system: defense needs material

Your immune cells divide very quickly during an infection. For every new cell, they need iron, zinc, folate and B12, among other things.

At the same time, your body plays a clever game during inflammation. The liver produces more hepcidin. This hormone holds iron in the stores and slows absorption in the gut.

That can be a protection, because many pathogens need iron too. But it also explains why ferritin can be high during inflammation even though your cells are short of iron. That's why ferritin always belongs together with an inflammation marker such as CRP.

Mechanistically plausible, human studies still thin: EPA and DHA are precursors of messengers that can actively end inflammation. These include the resolvins. How much this matters in everyday life is still open.

Metabolism: your inner garden and your muscles

Remember the garden? Your gut bacteria ferment fiber into short-chain fatty acids such as butyrate. Butyrate is the most important energy source for the cells of your colon lining.

These fatty acids also send signals to your immune system and your blood sugar metabolism. So a low-fiber diet could affect more systems than just your digestion.

On the other hand, your muscles need protein as material and creatine as an energy store. This is where animal foods have strengths.

How well your metabolism copes with a dietary pattern can also depend on your genes and your ancestry. More on this in the article Genetics, metabolism and ancestry.

Hormones: your timekeeper needs several building blocks

Your thyroid needs iodine as material for its hormones. The enzyme that builds iodine into the hormones contains iron. And your body needs selenium to activate the thyroid hormones.

An iron deficiency and an iodine deficiency could therefore show up in the same place: in your timekeeper. You can read how nutrition can influence your hormones and your blood sugar in the article Nutrition, hormones and blood sugar.

SystemImportant building blocksPossible signs of deficiency
Nervous systemIron, B12, DHA, creatineFatigue, concentration problems, tingling in hands or feet
Immune systemIron, zinc, folate, B12, EPA and DHAFrequent infections, slow recovery
MetabolismFiber, protein, creatineConstipation, declining strength
HormonesIodine, iron, seleniumFeeling cold, lack of drive, dry skin

These signs are nonspecific. They can have many causes and should be checked by a doctor.

A word about your reasons. Many people eat plant-based out of conviction, for the animals or for the climate. These reasons deserve respect. This article is not about your values, but about your nutrient supply. The two can be combined well.

Another perspective

Fatigue is not a character trait. It can be a signal that one of your systems is missing a building block. That turns self-blame into a question that can be answered.

And now you know why a missing building block rarely affects just one system.

Three levers for your everyday life

Maybe this feels like a lot right now. Iron, B12, omega-3, iodine, creatine, fiber. Do you now have to control every bite?

No. You don't need a list full of prohibitions. You need a few measurements and a few good habits.

Genuine freedom doesn't mean eating everything. It means choosing from knowledge instead of fear. When you know where your gaps are, you can close them in a targeted way. Then your plate can be a joy again.

Plant-forward with targeted building blocks

Plants form the basis of your plate: vegetables, legumes, whole grains, fruit, nuts and seeds. Where plants fall short, you add in a targeted way: B12, EPA and DHA, iodine, iron and, if needed, creatine. Depending on your diet, this can work through selected animal foods or through supplements. For EPA and DHA, I recommend an EPA oil or algae oil.

The question is not which side you're on. The question is what reaches your cells.

Three levers you can start with

1
Measure instead of guessing

Have your most important values tested before you change anything. These include ferritin with CRP and a blood count, holotranscobalamin or methylmalonic acid, vitamin D and the omega-3 index. Depending on your diet, iodine or zinc may be added. That way you'll see later whether your change has landed.

2
Use bioavailability

Combine iron-rich plants with vitamin C in the same meal, such as lentils with bell pepper. Drink coffee and black tea between meals instead. Soaking, sprouting and fermenting can lower the phytate content.

3
Targeted building blocks instead of switching camps

On a vegan diet, B12 is a must in any case. EPA and DHA come from an EPA oil or algae oil, iodine from iodized salt. If the iron from your diet is not enough, iron tablets or a correctly performed iron infusion can be options. Creatine may be worth considering. If you eat a lot of meat, more fiber and more plant variety are your most important building blocks.

You don't have to switch camps. You just need to know what you're missing. The rest is craft.

If you don't just want to read but want to get started right away: below this article you'll find the option to book an appointment.

And now you know why the honest answer is neither vegan nor steak, but: your nutrient supply.

Common questions: plant-based or animal-based

Is a vegan diet healthier than a mixed diet?

There is no blanket answer. In studies, a vegan diet is associated with lower body weight, better blood lipids and a lower cancer risk, but also with more bone fractures. What matters is how well your nutrient needs are met. A well-planned mixed diet and a well-planned vegan diet can both be healthy.

Is plant iron worse than animal iron?

Plant iron is absorbed less well. When your stores are empty, the estimated absorption from a vegetarian diet is 5 to 12 percent. From a mixed diet, it is 14 to 18 percent. Phytate from grains and legumes slows absorption, and vitamin C in the same meal can counteract this.

What is a good ferritin level?

The WHO sets the threshold for iron deficiency at 12 or 15 µg/l. A large US analysis arrived at a physiological threshold of about 25 µg/l for women. For reference, 1 µg/l equals 1 ng/ml. Clinically, I observe that many people only feel truly at their best with levels above roughly 100 ng/ml. This is a guide from my practice, not a study threshold. Ferritin should always be assessed together with an inflammation marker such as CRP.

Can an iron infusion make sense?

Yes, an iron infusion can be a good option. This applies, for example, when tablets are not enough, are not tolerated, or when inflammation is slowing absorption. What matters is that it is done correctly: with a clear indication, medical supervision and a follow-up check afterwards. In a study from Zurich, fatigue decreased mainly in women with very low ferritin.

Do I need B12 on a vegan diet?

Yes. In the EPIC-Oxford study, 52 percent of vegan men had a B12 deficiency. Reliable sources are fortified foods or a supplement. Algae and fermented foods are not considered reliable B12 sources. Holotranscobalamin or methylmalonic acid are suitable for monitoring.

Is flaxseed oil enough for omega-3?

Flaxseed oil provides ALA, the plant-based precursor. Your body converts only a small amount of it into EPA and DHA. In EPIC-Oxford, EPA and DHA were lower in vegetarian and vegan men, but stable. For EPA and DHA, an EPA oil or an algae oil are options to consider.

Is algae oil a good source of omega-3?

Algae oil provides DHA and, depending on the product, EPA as well, and it is vegan. In one study, people on a vegan diet took 254 mg of omega-3 from algae every day. After four months, their omega-3 index rose from 3.1 to 4.8 percent. There was, however, no control group. In my practice, I recommend an oil for this, not capsules.

Should vegetarians take creatine?

Creatine may be worth considering, because a plant-based diet provides hardly any creatine. In studies, vegetarians taking creatine performed better on memory and thinking than with placebo. The studies gave 5 grams daily for six weeks or 20 grams for five days. If you have kidney disease, you should discuss this with a doctor beforehand.

Is meat carcinogenic?

The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies processed meat as carcinogenic and red meat as probably carcinogenic. The classification describes how certain the evidence is, not how large the risk is. Amount and processing play a major role here.

What do people who eat a lot of meat tend to lack?

Fiber, folate, magnesium, vitamin E, calcium, vitamin D and polyunsaturated fatty acids are often in short supply. Fiber is especially important. In a large meta-analysis, the risk of death and of several diseases was 15 to 30 percent lower with a high intake. More vegetables, legumes, whole grains and nuts can help close this gap.

Do I get enough iodine on a vegan diet?

Often not. In a systematic review, people on a vegan diet had the lowest urinary iodine levels. In a Berlin study, urinary iodine was below 20 µg/l in one third of the people on a vegan diet. Iodized salt is a simple source. Seaweed, on the other hand, can provide a great deal of iodine and can therefore also lead to excessive intake.

Is plant-forward the same as vegan?

No. Plant-forward means that plants form the basis of your plate. Targeted supplements or selected animal foods are added where plants fall short. This applies, for example, to B12, EPA and DHA, iodine, iron or creatine. Vegan excludes animal foods entirely and therefore requires particularly good planning.

Which blood tests make sense on a plant-based diet?

Useful markers can include ferritin together with CRP and a blood count, holotranscobalamin or methylmalonic acid for B12, vitamin D and the omega-3 index. Depending on your situation, iodine, zinc or thyroid values may be added. Which values are right for you is best clarified with a doctor.

Do vegans have a higher risk of bone fractures?

In the EPIC-Oxford study, people on a vegan diet had more than twice the risk of hip fractures. This corresponded to 14.9 additional cases per 1,000 people over ten years. An association does not prove a cause. Calcium sources, vitamin D, enough protein and strength training can support your bones.

Plant-based or animal-based in the bigger picture

This article connects many topics from my nutrition series. Here you'll find the articles that explore individual building blocks in more depth.

SJ

Shukri Jarmoukli

Physician, Integrative Medicine · ViveCura Berlin

In my private practice, I work at the intersection of conventional medicine, functional medicine and Clinical Psychoneuroimmunology. When it comes to dietary patterns, I'm not interested in which camp turns out to be right. I'm interested in what reaches your cells and how you can check it.

This article does not replace medical advice. It is meant to help you ask better questions.

ViveCura, Privatpraxis Shukri Jarmoukli, Skalitzer Straße 137, 10999 Berlin

Scientific sources

  1. Hurrell R, Egli I. Iron bioavailability and dietary reference values. Am J Clin Nutr. 2010;91(5):1461S-1467S. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.2010.28674F · PMID: 20200263 [Review]
  2. Haider LM, Schwingshackl L, Hoffmann G, Ekmekcioglu C. The effect of vegetarian diets on iron status in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2018;58(8):1359-1374. DOI: 10.1080/10408398.2016.1259210 · PMID: 27880062 [Meta-analysis]
  3. Hallberg L, Brune M, Rossander L. Iron absorption in man: ascorbic acid and dose-dependent inhibition by phytate. Am J Clin Nutr. 1989;49(1):140-4. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/49.1.140 · PMID: 2911999 [Controlled absorption study in humans]
  4. Mei Z, Addo OY, Jefferds ME, Sharma AJ, Flores-Ayala RC, Brittenham GM. Physiologically based serum ferritin thresholds for iron deficiency in children and non-pregnant women: a US National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys (NHANES) serial cross-sectional study. Lancet Haematol. 2021;8(8):e572-e582. DOI: 10.1016/S2352-3026(21)00168-X · PMID: 34329578 [Real-world, NHANES cross-sectional study]
  5. Vaucher P, Druais PL, Waldvogel S, Favrat B. Effect of iron supplementation on fatigue in nonanemic menstruating women with low ferritin: a randomized controlled trial. CMAJ. 2012;184(11):1247-54. DOI: 10.1503/cmaj.110950 · PMID: 22777991 [RCT]
  6. Krayenbuehl PA, Battegay E, Breymann C, Furrer J, Schulthess G. Intravenous iron for the treatment of fatigue in nonanemic, premenopausal women with low serum ferritin concentration. Blood. 2011;118(12):3222-7. DOI: 10.1182/blood-2011-04-346304 · PMID: 21705493 [RCT]
  7. Pasricha SR, Tye-Din J, Muckenthaler MU, Swinkels DW. Iron deficiency. Lancet. 2021;397(10270):233-248. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(20)32594-0 · PMID: 33285139 [Review]
  8. Gilsing AM, Crowe FL, Lloyd-Wright Z, Sanders TA, Appleby PN, Allen NE, Key TJ. Serum concentrations of vitamin B12 and folate in British male omnivores, vegetarians and vegans: results from a cross-sectional analysis of the EPIC-Oxford cohort study. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2010;64(9):933-9. DOI: 10.1038/ejcn.2010.142 · PMID: 20648045 [Cohort, cross-sectional analysis]
  9. Pawlak R, Parrott SJ, Raj S, Cullum-Dugan D, Lucus D. How prevalent is vitamin B12 deficiency among vegetarians? Nutr Rev. 2013;71(2):110-7. DOI: 10.1111/nure.12001 · PMID: 23356638 [Review]
  10. Weikert C, Trefflich I, Menzel J, Obeid R, Longree A, Dierkes J, Meyer K, Herter-Aeberli I, Mai K, Stangl GI, Müller SM, Schwerdtle T, Lampen A, Abraham K. Vitamin and Mineral Status in a Vegan Diet. Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2020;117(35-36):575-582. DOI: 10.3238/arztebl.2020.0575 · PMID: 33161940 [Real-world, cross-sectional study]
  11. Rosell MS, Lloyd-Wright Z, Appleby PN, Sanders TA, Allen NE, Key TJ. Long-chain n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids in plasma in British meat-eating, vegetarian, and vegan men. Am J Clin Nutr. 2005;82(2):327-34. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn.82.2.327 · PMID: 16087975 [Cohort, cross-sectional analysis]
  12. Sarter B, Kelsey KS, Schwartz TA, Harris WS. Blood docosahexaenoic acid and eicosapentaenoic acid in vegans: Associations with age and gender and effects of an algal-derived omega-3 fatty acid supplement. Clin Nutr. 2015;34(2):212-8. DOI: 10.1016/j.clnu.2014.03.003 · PMID: 24679552 [Cohort, open-label supplementation without control group]
  13. Eveleigh ER, Coneyworth LJ, Avery A, Welham SJM. Vegans, Vegetarians, and Omnivores: How Does Dietary Choice Influence Iodine Intake? A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2020;12(6):1606. DOI: 10.3390/nu12061606 · PMID: 32486114 [Systematic review]
  14. Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Armstrong MEG, Fensom GK, Knuppel A, Papier K, Perez-Cornago A, Travis RC, Key TJ. Vegetarian and vegan diets and risks of total and site-specific fractures: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. BMC Med. 2020;18(1):353. DOI: 10.1186/s12916-020-01815-3 · PMID: 33222682 [Cohort]
  15. Selinger E, Neuenschwander M, Koller A, Gojda J, Kühn T, Schwingshackl L, Barbaresko J, Schlesinger S. Evidence of a vegan diet for health benefits and risks: an umbrella review of meta-analyses of observational and clinical studies. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2023;63(29):9926-9936. DOI: 10.1080/10408398.2022.2075311 · PMID: 37962057 [Systematic review, umbrella review]
  16. Rae C, Digney AL, McEwan SR, Bates TC. Oral creatine monohydrate supplementation improves brain performance: a double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over trial. Proc Biol Sci. 2003;270(1529):2147-50. DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2003.2492 · PMID: 14561278 [RCT, crossover]
  17. Benton D, Donohoe R. The influence of creatine supplementation on the cognitive functioning of vegetarians and omnivores. Br J Nutr. 2011;105(7):1100-5. DOI: 10.1017/S0007114510004733 · PMID: 21118604 [RCT]
  18. Kaviani M, Shaw K, Chilibeck PD. Benefits of Creatine Supplementation for Vegetarians Compared to Omnivorous Athletes: A Systematic Review. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020;17(9):3041. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17093041 · PMID: 32349356 [Systematic review]
  19. Neufingerl N, Eilander A. Nutrient Intake and Status in Adults Consuming Plant-Based Diets Compared to Meat-Eaters: A Systematic Review. Nutrients. 2021;14(1):29. DOI: 10.3390/nu14010029 · PMID: 35010904 [Systematic review]
  20. Satija A, Bhupathiraju SN, Spiegelman D, Chiuve SE, Manson JE, Willett W, Rexrode KM, Rimm EB, Hu FB. Healthful and Unhealthful Plant-Based Diets and the Risk of Coronary Heart Disease in U.S. Adults. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2017;70(4):411-422. DOI: 10.1016/j.jacc.2017.05.047 · PMID: 28728684 [Cohort]
  21. Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Bradbury KE, Perez-Cornago A, Travis RC, Clarke R, Key TJ. Risks of ischaemic heart disease and stroke in meat eaters, fish eaters, and vegetarians over 18 years of follow-up: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. BMJ. 2019;366:l4897. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.l4897 · PMID: 31484644 [Cohort]
  22. Reynolds A, Mann J, Cummings J, Winter N, Mete E, Te Morenga L. Carbohydrate quality and human health: a series of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Lancet. 2019;393(10170):434-445. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(18)31809-9 · PMID: 30638909 [Meta-analysis]
  23. Bouvard V, Loomis D, Guyton KZ, Grosse Y, Ghissassi FE, Benbrahim-Tallaa L, Guha N, Mattock H, Straif K. Carcinogenicity of consumption of red and processed meat. Lancet Oncol. 2015;16(16):1599-600. DOI: 10.1016/S1470-2045(15)00444-1 · PMID: 26514947 [Official document, IARC working group]
Transparency on the evidence

Most of the studies cited here are observational studies. They show associations, not causes. Randomized controlled trials are marked as RCT. The study figures in this article are taken from the abstracts of the original papers.

Nicole Neufingerl and Ans Eilander were working at Unilever when their review was published. Co-author Harris from the algae oil study is affiliated with OmegaQuant, a provider of the omega-3 index test. Both papers are included because their data fit the question well.

The IARC paper has no abstract. I therefore don't take any figures from it, only the classification and the terms. The guide value of ferritin above roughly 100 ng/ml is a clinical observation from my practice, not a study threshold.

This article does not replace medical advice.

Have questions or want to book an appointment?

We'd be happy to advise you personally at our practice.

Book appointment