Avoiding the yo-yo effect: why crash diets can make you gain weight
A radical diet can cost you muscle, turn up your hunger and throttle your energy expenditure. Studies from the Minnesota Starvation Experiment to the Biggest Loser follow-up show how the body pushes back afterward. Protein, strength training and a moderate pace can cushion this rebound.
Almost every diet works. For a few weeks. The more interesting question is not how fast you lose weight. It's what your body carries forward from that time.
Maybe this sounds familiar. On Monday you start, and this time you're doing it properly. Hardly any carbs, hardly any calories, onto the scale every morning.
The first weeks feel like a victory. Three kilos, five kilos. Then it turns into a slog. The hunger gets louder, your patience wears thinner, training gets harder.
At some point, the string snaps. A vacation, a stressful project, an evening when you just don't care anymore. And a few months later, the scale shows more than before you started.
If you recognize yourself in this: you're not alone, and you're not too weak. Your body probably did exactly what it was built to do. It tried to survive a famine.
“I did everything right. And now I weigh more than before.”
I know this pattern very well. A patient, whose personal details I'm deliberately leaving out here, came to see me in my practice with exactly these words. She had fought her way through a 5:2 diet for many weeks, in a very strict version of her own.
At first, the kilos came off quickly. Then the scale stalled, the hunger grew louder and she had less energy for everyday life. At some point, it tipped. A few months later, the scale showed more than at the start.
What interests me about courses like this doesn't show up on the scale. How much of the loss was muscle? How did the hunger change? And what did the constant restriction do to sleep and stress?
I can't prove that the crash phase alone caused the weight gain. I can't claim causality, but I do document the connection in time. It fits with what research has been describing for decades.
The lesson: It wasn't her willpower that failed. The strategy worked against her biology.
What to expect in this article
- Why you can weigh more after a diet than before
- What you lose on a crash diet besides fat
- What the Minnesota Starvation Experiment showed
- How far your body can switch into energy-saving mode
- Why leptin and ghrelin turn up your hunger
- Whether fast weight loss itself is the problem
- How protein and strength training can protect your muscles
- Three levers to avoid the yo-yo effect
Why do you sometimes weigh more after a crash diet than before?
It feels like a bad joke. You went without, you counted, you stuck with it. And in the end, you're heavier than before. How can that be?
That weight comes back after diets is well documented. A review from Columbia University in New York puts the relapse rate at over 80 percent: that's how many people return to their former body fat after initially successful weight loss. The authors see an interplay behind this: metabolism, behavior, hormones and the autonomic nervous system work together to defend the fat reserves.
The more interesting question is whether diets can even push you beyond your starting point. A team in Finland investigated exactly this with a clever trick: twins.
Researchers at Helsinki University Hospital followed 4,129 twins from the Finnish FinnTwin16 study from age 16 to 25. Those who had already intentionally lost more than 5 kilograms by age 25 gained weight faster afterward and became overweight more often. In women with two or more such dieting phases, the statistical odds of being overweight were 5.2 times as high as without dieting, in men 2.0 times. In identical twin pairs where only one twin had dieted, that twin was 0.4 BMI points heavier on average at age 25.
What this means for you: part of the connection is probably due to predisposition. But the twin comparison suggests that dieting itself might favor a small amount of later weight gain.
Pietiläinen KH, Saarni SE, Kaprio J, Rissanen A. Int J Obes (Lond). 2012, online 2011. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2011.160A team at the University of Fribourg in Switzerland reanalyzed classic studies on starvation and refeeding in humans. The authors themselves call the thesis “diets make you fat” controversial. Their finding: after a period of starvation, the body rebuilds fat faster than fat-free tissue, and this head start can lead to a surplus of fat. They consider the risk of getting fatter through dieting to be greater in lean people than in people with obesity.
What this means for you: if you're only slightly overweight and lose weight radically, you might be taking the biggest risk.
Dulloo AG, Jacquet J, Montani JP. Proc Nutr Soc. 2012. DOI: 10.1017/S0029665112000225Context matters here. Some people lose weight and keep it off. So diets are not a curse. But radical diets seem to challenge the body's defenses particularly strongly. I describe how your body defends its weight in general in the article on set point theory. Here, the question is what can make crash diets in particular so risky.
A yo-yo effect feels like personal failure. From a physiological point of view, it's more of a countermovement: your body is taking back what it needs to survive.
And now you know why the question “How much have I lost?” falls short. The better question is: what have I lost?
What do you lose on a crash diet besides fat?
The first days of a crash diet can feel great. Your pants fit more loosely, the scale drops every morning. But what exactly is disappearing?
A team from Kiel investigated this with elaborate measurement techniques. The result is likely to surprise many people.
Researchers at Kiel University repeated a kind of mini Minnesota experiment. Thirty-two men without obesity first ate 50 percent more than they needed for one week, then 50 percent less for three weeks, then more again for two weeks. During the three weeks of halved energy intake, they lost 114 grams of fat per day, but 159 grams of fat-free mass. Skeletal muscle shrank by 5 percent, the liver by 13 percent, the kidneys by 8 percent.
What this means for you: much of what the scale shows as success in the first weeks is not fat. Fat-free mass includes water, muscle and organs.
Müller MJ, Enderle J, Pourhassan M et al. Am J Clin Nutr. 2015. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.115.109173Imagine your body as a house. Fat is the storage cellar. Muscles and organs are the furniture and machines in the living space. A crash diet doesn't just empty the cellar. It also carries furniture out the door.
Through the lens of KPNI, Clinical Psychoneuroimmunology, the same Kiel study shows how many systems respond at the same time. In metabolism, resting metabolic rate fell by 266 kilocalories per day. In the hormonal system, leptin dropped by 44 percent, insulin by 54 percent, the thyroid hormone T3 by 39 percent and testosterone by 11 percent. The nervous system shifted down a gear: sympathetic nervous system activity fell by 38 percent, heart rate by 14 percent. This study provides no data on the immune system. On that front, the question remains open.
That leaves one question: does it matter for the yo-yo effect how much fat-free mass you lose? There are two studies on this that don't quite agree.
At Maastricht University, 57 people with overweight lost weight either slowly, on 1,250 kilocalories per day for 12 weeks, or quickly, on 500 kilocalories per day for 5 weeks. Both groups lost a similar amount, 8.2 and 9.0 kilograms, and regained a similar amount over the following months, 4.2 and 4.5 kilograms. But the percentage fat-free mass loss was considerably higher in the fast group, 8.8 versus 1.3 percent. And across all participants, a greater loss of fat-free mass went along with more weight regain.
What this means for you: pace alone was not the deciding factor here. But the more radical approach cost more fat-free mass, and it was precisely this loss that was linked to the rebound.
Vink RG, Roumans NJ, Arkenbosch LA, Mariman EC, van Baak MA. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2016. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21346A team from Trondheim and Birmingham, Alabama, followed 70 people with obesity through eight weeks of a very low-calorie diet with 550 to 660 kilocalories per day. They lost 17.5 kilograms on average, and the percentage fat-free mass loss was 20.4 percent. After statistical adjustment, this percentage did not predict weight regain after one year. A higher percentage, however, went along with a less favorable course of the hunger hormone ghrelin.
What this means for you: whether muscle loss directly drives the yo-yo effect has not been conclusively settled. One trail leads via hunger.
Martins C, Nymo S, Coutinho SR, Rehfeld JF, Hunter GR, Gower BA. J Nutr. 2023. DOI: 10.1016/j.tjnut.2023.03.026What can be taken from this: radical diets can cost more fat-free mass. Whether this loss directly drives the yo-yo effect is open. But several trails lead to hunger. And the oldest of these trails comes from an experiment that took place more than 80 years ago.
The scale measures weight, not tissue. A kilo less can be a kilo of fat. But it can also be water, muscle and organ mass.
And now you know why the fastest kilos often reveal the least about your fat loss.
What did the Minnesota Starvation Experiment show about the yo-yo effect?
Imagine volunteering to go hungry for science. Not for a few days. But until you've lost a quarter of your weight. That's exactly what 36 men in the US did during the Second World War.
Two researchers at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine in Baltimore traced the history of the Minnesota experiment and interviewed surviving participants. Thirty-six conscientious objectors took part in Ancel Keys' study at the University of Minnesota. Most of them lost more than 25 percent of their weight. Many suffered from anemia, exhaustion, lack of drive, extreme weakness, irritability, neurological deficits and fluid retention in the legs.
What this means for you: starving is not purely a matter of willpower. It changes the body, the nervous system and mood.
Kalm LM, Semba RD. J Nutr. 2005. DOI: 10.1093/jn/135.6.1347The starvation phase was followed by refeeding, first controlled, then unrestricted. And this is where it gets interesting for the yo-yo effect.
A team at the University of Geneva reanalyzed the original data of 12 men from the Minnesota experiment. After twelve weeks of controlled refeeding, the men were allowed to eat freely for eight weeks. How much they then ate beyond their former energy intake depended on how much fat they were still missing, but also on how much fat-free mass. The link with fat-free mass held up even after statistical adjustment for fat.
What this means for you: your body seems to count not only its fat reserves, but also its fat-free mass. As long as some of it is missing, hunger can stay louder.
Dulloo AG, Jacquet J, Girardier L. Am J Clin Nutr. 1997. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/65.3.717Imagine your body placing a big reorder after the starvation. It keeps ordering until the muscles are fully back as well. The problem: fat gets delivered faster than muscle. By the time the last bit of muscle is back, there can be more fat in storage than before the diet. Experts call this “fat overshooting”.
This is where the nervous system and metabolism mesh. Hunger is regulated in the brain, but the signals seem to come from fat tissue and fat-free tissue. The irritability and lack of drive in the Minnesota participants are a reminder that hunger is never just a gut feeling. It can also change your mood.
Cravings after a diet are not a sign of weakness. They can be your body's reorder: it wants back what it's missing, including muscle.
And now you know why it can pay off so much not to lose muscle in the first place.
Adaptive thermogenesis: how far does your body switch into energy-saving mode?
You're eating less than you have in a long time. And yet the scale barely moves anymore. Sound familiar?
Experts call one of the phenomena behind this adaptive thermogenesis. What it means: the body lowers its energy expenditure more than the loss of tissue can explain. Imagine a phone that switches into power-saving mode when the battery is low. It keeps running, but throttled.
At Rockefeller University in New York, researchers precisely measured the energy expenditure of 18 people with obesity and 23 people who had never had obesity, before and after a weight loss of 10 to 20 percent. In those who kept their weight at least 10 percent below their starting weight, total daily energy expenditure fell by 6 kilocalories per kilogram of fat-free mass in the participants who had never had obesity, and by 8 kilocalories in those with obesity. Conversely, expenditure rose when the participants gained 10 percent. The changes depended neither on body fat percentage nor on sex.
What this means for you: after weight loss, your body can run more economically than its new size would suggest. This applies to lean people and people with excess weight alike.
Leibel RL, Rosenbaum M, Hirsch J. N Engl J Med. 1995. DOI: 10.1056/NEJM199503093321001How quickly this energy-saving mode kicks in is shown, once again, by the Kiel study. The energy-saving effect became measurable after no more than three days of halved energy intake. It amounted to 108 kilocalories per day, just under half of the drop in resting metabolic rate, and was closely linked to the fall in insulin.
And what happens when weight loss is so extreme that it's broadcast on TV? That's exactly what a team from the US National Institutes of Health investigated.
Researchers at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases in Bethesda examined 14 participants of the TV show “The Biggest Loser” again six years after the 30-week competition. During the competition, they had lost 58.3 kilograms on average. Six years later, 41.0 kilograms had come back. Even so, their resting metabolic rate was still 704 kilocalories per day below baseline. Adjusted for body composition and age, an energy-saving effect of 499 kilocalories per day remained.
What this means for you: extreme weight loss can leave an imprint on metabolism that lasts a long time. Surprisingly, those who had kept off more weight actually showed the stronger energy-saving effect.
Fothergill E, Guo J, Howard L et al. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2016. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21538average weight loss during the 30-week competition
of that regained six years later
lower resting metabolic rate per day after six years, adjusted for body composition and age
Data from Fothergill et al. 2016, 14 participants of “The Biggest Loser”. Extreme conditions, not transferable to every diet.
That sounds like a permanently damaged metabolism. But Kevin Hall of the same institute, one of the authors, later reinterpreted the data. The participants had increased their physical activity sharply and permanently. This may have prompted the body to throttle its resting metabolic rate so that total expenditure didn't rise too much. This interpretation would explain why the energy-saving effect was largest in the most active participants, and why programs with less exercise have not measured such large effects.
The same research group found something else: those who had kept off more weight after six years, on average 24.9 percent of their weight, had increased their physical activity by 160 percent. Among those who had regained weight, the figure was 34 percent. The two groups barely differed in energy intake. I'll come back to this in the section on levers.
How large is the energy-saving effect after a more ordinary weight loss? A team at the University of Alabama at Birmingham followed 171 women with overweight for two years and measured resting metabolic rate only when their weight was stable. After an average weight loss of 12 kilograms, the team found a small energy-saving effect of 54 kilocalories per day, which did not predict weight regain. In a subgroup with measurements at all time points, it was no longer detectable after one and two years. Even so, after two years the women had regained 89 percent of the weight they had lost.
What this means for you: after moderate weight loss, the energy-saving mode seems to be small. The yo-yo effect can still happen. Then other drivers come into focus, above all hunger.
Martins C, Gower BA, Hill JO, Hunter GR. Am J Clin Nutr. 2020. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/nqaa086Energy-saving mode sounds like a broken metabolism. The data point more toward a smart thermostat that pushes back harder during extreme programs than during moderate ones.
And now you know why radical diets in particular can provoke the strongest pushback.
Leptin and ghrelin: why does hunger get louder after a diet?
Do you know that kind of hunger that doesn't come from your stomach, but from your head? The kind that pulls you to the fridge in the evening, even though you should be full?
Two hormones play a leading role here. Leptin is something like your body's fuel gauge. It comes from fat tissue and tells the brain how full the reserves are. Ghrelin is more like the bell that calls you to the table. After a diet, the fuel gauge can be stuck on reserve while the bell rings louder.
A team at the University of Melbourne put 50 people with overweight or obesity on a very low-calorie diet for ten weeks. They lost 13.5 kilograms on average. One year after the weight loss, leptin was still lower than before the diet and ghrelin still higher, and feelings of hunger were stronger, too. Other messengers of hunger and satiety, such as peptide YY and cholecystokinin, had not returned to their baseline levels either.
What this means for you: after a crash diet, the extra hunger doesn't go away after a few weeks. Your hormones can still be turning it up a year later.
Sumithran P, Prendergast LA, Delbridge E et al. N Engl J Med. 2011. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1105816A team led by Polidori, with the involvement of the US institute NIDDK, calculated how strongly appetite works against weight loss. It was based on data from a one-year, placebo-controlled study of 153 people who received a diabetes medication. This drug causes sugar to be excreted in the urine, so the participants lost weight without consciously feeling the deficit. For every kilogram lost, they ate about 100 kilocalories more per day than at the start, more than three times the adjustment in energy expenditure.
What this means for you: the strongest opponent in maintaining your weight is probably not the energy-saving mode, but appetite.
Polidori D, Sanghvi A, Seeley RJ, Hall KD. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2016. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21653The researchers from New York who describe the relapse rate of over 80 percent see leptin as a central mediator of this pushback. When fat drops, leptin drops, and the brain reads this as: scarcity. You can read more about these hormones in the article on leptin and insulin and in the article on hunger and satiety.
And what about stress? What going hungry can do to cortisol
Diets often don't just feel hungry. They also feel tense. That's not just in your head.
A team led by Tomiyama in California randomly assigned 121 women to four groups for three weeks: counting calories or not, restricting calories or not. Those restricted to 1,200 kilocalories per day released more cortisol overall, measured in saliva. Those who counted calories felt more stressed.
What this means for you: to your body, a diet is not just a math problem. It can also be a stress signal.
Tomiyama AJ, Mann T, Vinas D, Hunger JM, Dejager J, Taylor SE. Psychosom Med. 2010. DOI: 10.1097/PSY.0b013e3181d9523cThis shows how closely the KPNI systems are interwoven. In the hormonal system, satiety signals fall, hunger signals rise, and cortisol can increase. The nervous system processes these signals in the brain and adjusts your drive to eat. At the same time, metabolism saves energy. The studies cited here provide no data on the immune system, and I don't want to claim anything there that hasn't been measured. I describe how stress can shape eating behavior in the article on emotional eating. Why lack of sleep can make you hungry is explained in the article on sleep and weight loss.
How the yo-yo cycle can unfold
Radical deficit
Very little energy, often little protein and no strength training.
Losing more than fat
Besides fat, water, muscle and organ mass are lost.
Counter-regulation
Leptin falls, ghrelin rises, energy expenditure is throttled.
Rebound with a surplus
Fat comes back faster than muscle. Hunger can persist until fat-free mass has returned as well.
More hunger after a diet is not proof that you're too weak. It's a signal from your hormonal system that you can take seriously and answer wisely, instead of fighting it.
And now you know why, when it comes to maintaining your weight, satiety can matter more than restriction.
Is fast weight loss itself the problem?
Maybe you're thinking now: then I'll just lose weight very slowly. Half a kilo a month, and all is well. It's not quite that simple.
A team at the University of Melbourne asked exactly this question in a randomized trial. Two hundred people with obesity were to lose 15 percent of their weight, either quickly in 12 weeks or slowly in 36 weeks. With the fast program, 81 percent achieved a weight loss of at least 12.5 percent, compared with 50 percent on the slow one. After 144 weeks on a maintenance diet, both groups had regained most of the weight: 71.2 percent after slow and 70.5 percent after fast weight loss.
What this means for you: in this study, pace did not decide the yo-yo effect. Both paths ended up in a similar place.
Purcell K, Sumithran P, Prendergast LA, Bouniu CJ, Delbridge E, Proietto J. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol. 2014. DOI: 10.1016/S2213-8587(14)70200-1The Maastricht study mentioned above also found no difference in weight regain between fast and slow. The difference lay elsewhere: in fat-free mass. And what about 5:2, the approach from the story at the beginning?
A team from Manchester compared two approaches, each with 25 percent less energy, in 107 premenopausal women. One group ate a sharply reduced diet on two days per week, at about 2,710 kilojoules per day. The other ate somewhat less on all seven days, at about 6,276 kilojoules per day. After six months, both groups had lost a similar amount, minus 6.4 and minus 5.6 kilograms.
What this means for you: 5:2 is not a crash diet per se. What matters is how you put it into practice.
Harvie MN, Pegington M, Mattson MP et al. Int J Obes (Lond). 2011, online 2010. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2010.1715:2 can become a crash diet if you barely eat on the remaining days too, protein falls short and strength training is missing. I describe how you can put alternate-day fasting into perspective in the article on 5:2 and alternate-day fasting.
If pace alone doesn't decide, what does? The studies in this article point to three things: what you lose while losing weight, how loud your hunger gets afterward and whether you have a plan for the time after. Above all, a moderate pace makes it easier for you to keep an eye on all three.
What a crash diet often brings with it
A very large deficit, little protein, lots of cardio without strength training and no plan for the time afterward. The focus is on the scale. The risk: more loss of fat-free mass, louder hunger, stronger counter-regulation.
What a sustainable approach can do differently
A moderate deficit, protein at every meal, strength training as a regular part of the plan, planned maintenance phases and more everyday movement for the long term. The focus is on body composition. The opportunity: more fat loss while better preserving muscle.
Slow is not an end in itself. Slow is the pace at which you can keep your muscles, feel full and build habits.
And now you know why it's less about speed than about what you hold on to along the way.
How can you protect your muscles while losing weight?
Many people who want to lose weight go running. And running. Strength training often doesn't feature in the plan at all. Yet it might be one of the most important building blocks of weight loss.
At West Virginia University, 20 adults consumed only 800 kilocalories per day as a liquid diet for twelve weeks. Half of them exercised four times a week for an hour, walking, cycling or climbing stairs. The other half did intense strength training three times a week. In the endurance group, lean body mass fell from 51 to 47 kilograms, and resting metabolic rate over 24 hours dropped. In the strength group, no fat-free mass was lost, and resting metabolic rate per kilogram even rose.
What this means for you: even under very harsh conditions, strength training can protect muscle. A small study, but a clear signal.
Bryner RW, Ullrich IH, Sauers J et al. J Am Coll Nutr. 1999. DOI: 10.1080/07315724.1999.10718838To be clear, this is not a case for eating 800 kilocalories a day. It only shows how powerful the training stimulus can be.
A team from Houston and Albuquerque followed 160 older adults with obesity through a weight loss program combined with endurance training, strength training or both, plus a control group without a program. In all training groups, weight fell by 9 percent. But lean mass declined to different degrees: by 5 percent with endurance training alone, by 3 percent with the combination and by 2 percent with strength training. Physical performance improved most with the combination.
What this means for you: same scale, different composition. Especially in the second half of life, strength training can make the difference when you lose weight.
Villareal DT, Aguirre L, Gurney AB et al. N Engl J Med. 2017. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1616338If you use a weight-loss injection, this question becomes even more important. You can read more about this in the article on muscle loss on weight-loss injections. I describe what can happen after stopping in the article Stopping weight-loss injections.
And protein?
Muscles need two signals: load and building material. The building material is called protein.
At McMaster University in Canada, 40 young men ate around 40 percent less energy than they needed for four weeks and did strength and interval training six days a week. Half of them received 2.4 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, the other half 1.2 grams. With more protein, lean mass increased by 1.2 kilograms despite the deficit. With less, it increased by 0.1 kilograms. And the higher-protein group lost more fat, 4.8 versus 3.5 kilograms.
What this means for you: under a large deficit with hard training, more protein can make the difference. These were young, very active men. For most people, the usual ranges are lower.
Longland TM, Oikawa SY, Mitchell CJ, Devries MC, Phillips SM. Am J Clin Nutr. 2016. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.115.119339A team from the University of South Australia in Adelaide pooled 24 studies with 1,063 people. With the same number of calories, a higher-protein, low-fat diet led on average to 0.79 kilograms more weight loss and 0.87 kilograms more fat loss. At the same time, 0.43 kilograms more fat-free mass was preserved, and resting metabolic rate dropped less.
What this means for you: protein is no magic bullet. The effects are modest, but they point in the same direction: more fat loss, better preserved fat-free mass.
Wycherley TP, Moran LJ, Clifton PM, Noakes M, Brinkworth GD. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.112.044321An international group of authors led by Leidy summarized how much protein can make sense. For weight loss phases, they arrive at 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, ideally with at least about 25 to 30 grams per meal. They see dietary adherence as the most important reason why long-term studies produce inconsistent results: the benefit showed up mainly in those who stuck with it.
A team at Washington University in St. Louis adds two points. Protein should be adequate, but not excessive. And both endurance and strength training can protect muscle mass during weight loss, while strength training can also improve strength.
Seen through the KPNI lens, muscle is not decoration. For metabolism, it is active tissue: in the West Virginia study, resting metabolic rate was maintained with strength training, and in the Adelaide meta-analysis, it dropped less with more protein. In the hormonal system, the Canadian study found a link between cortisol and the changes in fat and lean mass, although it explained only a small part of them. I describe why muscle mass tends to dwindle over the years anyway in the article on age-related muscle loss.
When losing weight, most people ask: how much less should I eat? The better question might be: what do I give my muscles so that they stay?
Protein and strength training are something like insurance for your metabolism. And now you know why dumbbells belong in a weight loss plan just as much as running shoes.
Avoiding the yo-yo effect: which levers can you use?
Maybe you're asking yourself now: so what do I do differently starting tomorrow? The good news: you don't have to get tougher. Smarter, if anything.
I find one idea from Australia particularly interesting here, because it deliberately takes away the body's constant signal of scarcity.
In the MATADOR study by the University of Tasmania and Queensland University of Technology, 51 men with obesity spent a total of 16 weeks in a deficit, at 67 percent of their maintenance needs. One group did this in one go. The other did it in two-week blocks, each followed by two weeks of energy-balanced eating, over a total of 30 weeks. Among those who took part as planned, the group with breaks lost more weight, 14.1 versus 9.1 kilograms, and more fat, 12.3 versus 8.0 kilograms. After accounting for the change in body composition, their resting metabolic rate dropped less.
What this means for you: planned breaks at maintenance level are not failure. They might signal to your body: no famine. However, this is a single, fairly small study in men.
Byrne NM, Sainsbury A, King NA, Hills AP, Wood RE. Int J Obes (Lond). 2018, online 2017. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2017.206This fits with the finding from the Biggest Loser follow-up: those who had maintained their weight differed mainly in their permanently increased physical activity, and hardly in their eating. Maintaining weight is apparently a discipline of its own, with its own tools.
Moderate instead of radical
Choose a deficit that lets you stay full, capable and well rested. Ask yourself with every measure: could I still do this a year from now? In the Maastricht study, the slower program cost considerably less fat-free mass. Very low-calorie phases belong under medical supervision.
Muscles first
Plan protein into every meal and do strength training several times a week, with a slowly increasing load. For weight loss phases, the literature cites 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day. Measure your progress not only on the scale, but also by strength, waist circumference and, if possible, body composition.
Plan what comes after from the start
Set maintenance phases before hunger forces you into them. In the MATADOR study, planned breaks at maintenance level were part of the concept. Keep your everyday movement high for the long term, as the Biggest Loser participants who maintained their weight better did. And take sleep and stress seriously, because both can affect hunger and hormones.
That's why, in our metabolic work at ViveCura, we don't just look at weight when someone has a long dieting history. We ask what was lost during previous diets, how hunger and satiety have changed, how sleep and stress are going and whether hormones such as insulin or the thyroid are involved. I describe why the thyroid can play a role in weight in the article Hypothyroidism and weight. Conventional nutritional medicine is important and well founded here. An integrative view can add these layers to it.
I find a perspective from anthroposophic medicine fitting here. In it, rhythm plays a major role: the alternation of tension and relaxation, of breathing in and breathing out. That's an image, not a scientific statement. But it sums up what the studies suggest: the body responds to extremes with pushback, and to rhythm more with adaptation.
Your body doesn't forget a famine as quickly as you forget a diet.
- Very low-calorie diets: Programs with very little energy belong under medical supervision. In the Melbourne study on pace, one person in the fast group developed gallbladder inflammation that required surgery.
- Pre-existing conditions and medications: If you take medication for diabetes or high blood pressure, a sharp calorie reduction can make an adjustment necessary. Never change medications on your own.
- Kidneys: If you have kidney disease, please check with your doctor before increasing your protein intake.
- Eating behavior: If dieting comes with loss of control, binge eating, vomiting or severe distress for you, please talk about it openly. In that case, professional support matters more than any meal plan.
- Pregnancy and breastfeeding: Crash diets are not an option here. More on this in the article on losing weight after pregnancy.
Established by randomized trials and a meta-analysis: higher-protein diets and strength training can preserve fat-free mass during weight loss. In two randomized trials, the pace of weight loss alone did not determine weight regain. Well described in human studies: after weight loss, hunger hormones can remain shifted for at least a year, and energy expenditure can drop more than the lower weight explains. Controversial: how large the energy-saving mode is in the long term and whether it predicts weight regain. Whether muscle loss directly drives the yo-yo effect. And whether diets themselves make you gain weight or rather reveal a predisposition. What I observe clinically: people with a long dieting history are often relieved when the goal is no longer just a smaller number, but a body that gets stronger. That's experience, not a study.
In the end, this is about more than a number. It's about not starting over every spring. Without fear of vacations, of Christmas, of the next family celebration. A stable weight is not a reward for toughness. It is freedom.
A crash diet promises quick kilos. Your body can respond with muscle loss, louder hunger and a metabolism turned down to a low flame. And then it takes back what it believes it has lost.
The sustainable path is quieter: moderate, muscle-preserving, with an eye on hormones, sleep and stress. Not faster to your goal, but with better chances of staying there.
More from the Weight Loss Guide
Keep reading in the guide
- Understanding weight holistically
- Why am I not losing weight when I eat so little?
- Set point theory
- Why calorie counting fails for many people
- The calorie myth: quality over quantity
- Boosting your metabolism: what counts
- Leptin and insulin
- Understanding hunger and satiety
- Cravings: where they come from
- Understanding emotional eating
- Sleep and weight loss
- Unprocessed food and satiety
- Boosting GLP-1 naturally
- Insulin resistance and weight loss
- Recognizing insulin resistance
- Silent inflammation and weight
- What a CGM sensor shows
- Avoiding blood sugar spikes
- Apple cider vinegar for weight loss
- Does alcohol make you gain weight?
- Hypothyroidism and weight
- Losing weight during menopause
- Losing weight after pregnancy
- Breast milk: growth despite few calories
- Weight-loss injections: what they can do
- Weight-loss injections and GLP-1 explained
- Mounjaro and tirzepatide
- Weight-loss injections: side effects
- Weight-loss injections and muscle loss
- Protecting your muscles on weight-loss injections
- Stopping weight-loss injections and the yo-yo effect
- The plan after weight-loss injections
Where this topic connects
Muscles, fasting, hormones and weight are closely linked. These articles explore the neighboring areas in more depth.
Alternate-day fasting (5:2)
Who full-day fasting can be worthwhile for, and who it isn't.
FastingFasting and muscle preservation
Whether you lose muscle while fasting, and what it depends on.
FastingStrength training and blood sugar
Why your muscles are your body's largest sugar store.
ExerciseAge-related muscle loss
Why sarcopenia starts earlier than you might think.
ExerciseCortisol too high?
What's behind the stress hormone, and what isn't.
HormonesThyroid and weight
Why losing weight can be harder with an underactive thyroid.
ThyroidFrequently asked questions about the yo-yo effect
What is the yo-yo effect?
Can crash diets make you gain weight?
How long does the body stay in energy-saving mode after a diet?
Is losing weight fast worse than losing it slowly?
How much protein do I need when losing weight?
Can strength training cushion the yo-yo effect?
Is 5:2 or intermittent fasting a crash diet?
What is a diet break, and does it help?
Is the yo-yo effect my own fault?
How can I tell whether I'm losing muscle instead of fat?
Sources
All studies were checked via PubMed against title, authors, year, journal and DOI, and key DOIs were additionally checked via the Crossref DOI registry. Figures on study results come from the respective abstracts. The study type is given in square brackets. For context: the statements on protein and strength training are based on randomized trials and a meta-analysis, mostly of short duration. The data on metabolism and hormones after dieting come from metabolic studies and follow-up studies in humans, some with small groups. Whether diets themselves cause later weight gain is controversial and is based on observational data and reanalyses.
- Rosenbaum M, Leibel RL. Adaptive thermogenesis in humans. Int J Obes (Lond). 2010;34 Suppl 1:S47-55. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2010.184 · PMID 20935667 [Mechanistic review]
- Pietiläinen KH, Saarni SE, Kaprio J, Rissanen A. Does dieting make you fat? A twin study. Int J Obes (Lond). 2012;36(3):456-64, online 2011. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2011.160 · PMID 21829159 [Cohort, FinnTwin16 twin study, n=4,129]
- Dulloo AG, Jacquet J, Montani JP. How dieting makes some fatter: from a perspective of human body composition autoregulation. Proc Nutr Soc. 2012;71(3):379-89. DOI: 10.1017/S0029665112000225 · PMID 22475574 [Mechanistic review, reanalysis of human studies on starvation and refeeding]
- Müller MJ, Enderle J, Pourhassan M et al. Metabolic adaptation to caloric restriction and subsequent refeeding: the Minnesota Starvation Experiment revisited. Am J Clin Nutr. 2015;102(4):807-19. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.115.109173 · PMID 26399868 [Pathophysiology, controlled feeding study, n=32]
- Vink RG, Roumans NJ, Arkenbosch LA, Mariman EC, van Baak MA. The effect of rate of weight loss on long-term weight regain in adults with overweight and obesity. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2016;24(2):321-7. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21346 · PMID 26813524 [RCT, n=57]
- Martins C, Nymo S, Coutinho SR, Rehfeld JF, Hunter GR, Gower BA. Association between Fat-Free Mass Loss, Changes in Appetite, and Weight Regain in Individuals with Obesity. J Nutr. 2023;153(5):1330-1337. DOI: 10.1016/j.tjnut.2023.03.026 · PMID 36963504 [Cohort, intervention study with follow-up, n=70]
- Kalm LM, Semba RD. They starved so that others be better fed: remembering Ancel Keys and the Minnesota experiment. J Nutr. 2005;135(6):1347-52. DOI: 10.1093/jn/135.6.1347 · PMID 15930436 [Review, historical]
- Dulloo AG, Jacquet J, Girardier L. Poststarvation hyperphagia and body fat overshooting in humans: a role for feedback signals from lean and fat tissues. Am J Clin Nutr. 1997;65(3):717-23. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/65.3.717 · PMID 9062520 [Pathophysiology, reanalysis of the Minnesota Experiment, n=12]
- Leibel RL, Rosenbaum M, Hirsch J. Changes in energy expenditure resulting from altered body weight. N Engl J Med. 1995;332(10):621-8. DOI: 10.1056/NEJM199503093321001 · PMID 7632212 [Pathophysiology, controlled metabolic study, n=41]
- Fothergill E, Guo J, Howard L et al. Persistent metabolic adaptation 6 years after “The Biggest Loser” competition. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2016;24(8):1612-9. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21538 · PMID 27136388 [Cohort, follow-up after 6 years, n=14]
- Hall KD. Energy compensation and metabolic adaptation: “The Biggest Loser” study reinterpreted. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2022;30(1):11-13, online 2021. DOI: 10.1002/oby.23308 · PMID 34816627 [Review, perspective]
- Kerns JC, Guo J, Fothergill E et al. Increased Physical Activity Associated with Less Weight Regain Six Years After “The Biggest Loser” Competition. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2017;25(11):1838-1843. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21986 · PMID 29086499 [Cohort, follow-up after 6 years, n=14]
- Martins C, Gower BA, Hill JO, Hunter GR. Metabolic adaptation is not a major barrier to weight-loss maintenance. Am J Clin Nutr. 2020;112(3):558-565. DOI: 10.1093/ajcn/nqaa086 · PMID 32386226 [Cohort, intervention study with 2 years of follow-up, n=171]
- Sumithran P, Prendergast LA, Delbridge E et al. Long-term persistence of hormonal adaptations to weight loss. N Engl J Med. 2011;365(17):1597-604. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1105816 · PMID 22029981 [Pathophysiology, prospective intervention study, n=50]
- Polidori D, Sanghvi A, Seeley RJ, Hall KD. How Strongly Does Appetite Counter Weight Loss? Quantification of the Feedback Control of Human Energy Intake. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2016;24(11):2289-2295. DOI: 10.1002/oby.21653 · PMID 27804272 [RCT, mathematical analysis of the trial data, n=153]
- Tomiyama AJ, Mann T, Vinas D, Hunger JM, Dejager J, Taylor SE. Low calorie dieting increases cortisol. Psychosom Med. 2010;72(4):357-64. DOI: 10.1097/PSY.0b013e3181d9523c · PMID 20368473 [RCT, 2x2 design, n=121, 3 weeks]
- Purcell K, Sumithran P, Prendergast LA, Bouniu CJ, Delbridge E, Proietto J. The effect of rate of weight loss on long-term weight management: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol. 2014;2(12):954-62. DOI: 10.1016/S2213-8587(14)70200-1 · PMID 25459211 [RCT, n=200]
- Harvie MN, Pegington M, Mattson MP et al. The effects of intermittent or continuous energy restriction on weight loss and metabolic disease risk markers: a randomized trial in young overweight women. Int J Obes (Lond). 2011;35(5):714-27, online 2010. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2010.171 · PMID 20921964 [RCT, n=107, 6 months]
- Bryner RW, Ullrich IH, Sauers J et al. Effects of resistance vs. aerobic training combined with an 800 calorie liquid diet on lean body mass and resting metabolic rate. J Am Coll Nutr. 1999;18(2):115-21. DOI: 10.1080/07315724.1999.10718838 · PMID 10204826 [RCT, n=20, 12 weeks]
- Villareal DT, Aguirre L, Gurney AB et al. Aerobic or Resistance Exercise, or Both, in Dieting Obese Older Adults. N Engl J Med. 2017;376(20):1943-1955. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1616338 · PMID 28514618 [RCT, n=160, 6 months]
- Longland TM, Oikawa SY, Mitchell CJ, Devries MC, Phillips SM. Higher compared with lower dietary protein during an energy deficit combined with intense exercise promotes greater lean mass gain and fat mass loss: a randomized trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 2016;103(3):738-46. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.115.119339 · PMID 26817506 [RCT, n=40, 4 weeks]
- Wycherley TP, Moran LJ, Clifton PM, Noakes M, Brinkworth GD. Effects of energy-restricted high-protein, low-fat compared with standard-protein, low-fat diets: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012;96(6):1281-98. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.112.044321 · PMID 23097268 [Meta-analysis, k=24 RCTs, n=1,063]
- Leidy HJ, Clifton PM, Astrup A et al. The role of protein in weight loss and maintenance. Am J Clin Nutr. 2015;101(6):1320S-1329S. DOI: 10.3945/ajcn.114.084038 · PMID 25926512 [Review]
- Cava E, Yeat NC, Mittendorfer B. Preserving Healthy Muscle during Weight Loss. Adv Nutr. 2017;8(3):511-519. DOI: 10.3945/an.116.014506 · PMID 28507015 [Review]
- Byrne NM, Sainsbury A, King NA, Hills AP, Wood RE. Intermittent energy restriction improves weight loss efficiency in obese men: the MATADOR study. Int J Obes (Lond). 2018;42(2):129-138, online 2017. DOI: 10.1038/ijo.2017.206 · PMID 28925405 [RCT, n=51 randomized, 36 analyzed per protocol]
This article is for information only and does not replace medical advice. It describes connections from research and clinical experience, not individual treatment instructions. Very low-calorie diets, losing weight with pre-existing conditions such as diabetes, kidney disease or eating disorders, and losing weight during pregnancy and breastfeeding belong under medical supervision.